MCB First Annual All-AL Central Team

Welcome to the first annual All- AL Central team. As is the case with any series I start, please note that there are no guarantees that this series will continue beyond this year. With that in mind, some ground-rules: Every team in the division must be represented on the all-division team. To be eligible, a player must have played within the division for at least 1/3 of the season, and must end the year with a team in the division. That’s pretty much it. Honors bestowed after the jump.

Catcher- Joe Mauer (Min)- This one was easy. Coming off an MVP season in 2009, Mauer saw his home run totals drop dramatically this year. Still, he posted a .327 average and an OPS+ of 137 while playing in 137 games. Considering the other catchers in the Central, it was no contest.

First Base- Miguel Cabrera (Det)- Another pick that was fairly easy. Cabrera put up MVP numbers all season long and did so without much help in the lineup, especially over the final two months. He ended the season on the shelf, but before he was done he clubbed 38 homers and lead the league with 126 RBI to go with his .328 average and 179 OPS+. Dude can rake.

Second Base- Orlando Hudson (Min)- Hudson wins this spot on consistency alone, really. His defense was good and he provided a solid hitter at the two-spot for the Twins. His offensive numbers aren’t great (.268 average, .328 OBP), but given that every other team in the Central used multiple players at second base much more often, I’ll go with Hudson here.

Shortstop- Alexei Ramirez (CWS)- Ramirez made a strong surge down the stretch and narrowly passed Yuniesky Betancourt for this honor. Ramirez provided 18 homers and 70 RBI to go along with a respectable .282 average and 97 OPS+. It was those numbers that pushed him ahead.

Third Base- Wilson Betemit (KC)- Our first Royal makes the team in a close contest over two others. Betemit may have finally had his breakthrough after years of wasted potential, but when he got his shot in Kansas City, he ran with hit. Betemit had only 84 games this year, but he produced 13 home runs, 20 doubles, and a slash line of .297/.378/.511 for an OPS+ of 141.

Left Field- Delmon Young (Min)- Young will garner some MVP votes after his own breakout campaign this year. He stepped up in a big way and helped carry the Twins offense with a .298 average, 46 doubles, 21 homers, and a team-leading 112 RBI. Young’s career year also produced an OPS+ of 121.

Center Field- Austin Jackson (Det)- Okay, this might be a homer pick, but it’s my blog and I’m a Tigers fan. AJax was better than anyone could have hoped for in his first big league action. The man that should win the Rookie of the Year award lead the Tigers in hits, triples, and stolen bases while providing highlight reel type defensive work. His average finally dipped below .300 at the end of the year, but his .293 average and .345 OBP helped to offset his league leading strikeout total.

Right Field- Shin-Soo Choo (Cle)- Choo isn’t here because someone from the Indians had to be, he’s here because he earned it. Choo posted an OPS+ of 148 and belted 22 homers to go with 22 steals and 90 RBI. No other Indian had more than 50 driven in this year. He lead the Tribe in almost every offensive category, most by a wide margin, and he has a bazooka of an arm as well.

Designated Hitter- Jim Thome (Min)- I hadn’t planned to reserve this spot for a full-time DH, but Thome’s 178 OPS+ was too much to ignore. He lead the Twins with 25 home runs and a .627 slugging average. All he does is mash taters.

Starting Staff

Francisco Liriano (Min)- The Twins ace southpaw was named the Comeback Player of the Year for his 14-10 record and 3.62 ERA. He fanned over 200 hitters in just 191 innings and allowed only nine home runs all year.

Justin Verlander (Det)- Verlander lead the division with 219 strikeouts and posted an 18-9 record and 3.37 ERA. This year marked the fourth time in his five seasons that he recorded at least 17 wins.

Max Scherzer (Det)- Scherzer struggled so mightily early in the year that he was optioned to AAA for two weeks. After his recall, Scherzer simply dominated the American League. His 12-11 record and 3.50 ERA may not impress you, but from May 30 through the end of the season, he went 11-7 with an ERA of 2.46 and fanned 158 batters in 153 innings pitched.

Edwin Jackson (CWS)- Acquired at the trade deadline, Jackson’s return to the Central was quite a success. He made just 11 starts for the White Sox, but in those 75 innings, he posted a strikeout-to-walk ratio of better than 4-to-1. Jackson had a 4-2 record and 3.44 ERA with Chicago this year.

Carl Pavano (Min)- Pavano started off with a tremendous first half, but faded a bit down the stretch. He still wound up leading the Twins with a 17-10 record and his 3.75 ERA was quite nice as well.


Joakim Soria (KC)- The Mexicutioner blew only two saves all year and posted a 1.78 ERA in 66 games. Soria saved 43 games for a Royals team that won only 67 times. Did you know the Dodgers released this guy?

Chris Perez (Cle)- See? Choo wasn’t there just to represent the Indians. Perez took over as the closer after Kerry Wood was terrible (and injured) in that role. Pure Rage offered up 23 saves and fanned nearly a batter per inning while posting a 1.71 ERA for the Tribe.

Jose Valverde (Det)- Papa Grande was an all-star for the Tigers after leading the AL in saves at the break. His suffered through some injuries (and severe overuse) in the second half, but his overall numbers are still good enough to make the list. 3.00 ERA, 26 saves and 63 strikeouts in 63 innings of work.

Jesse Crain (Min)- Crain worked in 71 games for the Twins, posting 62 strikeouts in 68 innings of work. Crain allowed just nine of the 39 base runners he inherited to score.

Matt Thornton (CWS)- The White Sox had one of the best bullpens in the league and Thornton was a huge reason why. He lead the club in appearances and fanned 81 batters in 60 innings, posting a 4-to-1 K:BB ratio.  Opposing batters hit just .191 against him overall, but lefties batted only .175.

Chris Sale (CWS)- Sale was the White Sox first round pick this year and made a huge impact on their bullpen right away. He appeared in only 21 games, but he fanned 32 batters in just 23 innings of work. Opponents hit just .185 against him, but it was the right handed hitters who had no chance against this southpaw, posting an average of just .120.


C- Carlos Santana (Cle)- Seriously, have you seen how bad the catchers were in this division? Santana got just 150 at bats in before his knee was destroyed, but I’d still take him over anyone not named Mauer.

IF- Paul Konerko (CWS)- Just keeps hitting bombs. 39 homers and 111 RBI, but he’s still no Cabrera.

IF- Omar Vizquel (CWS)- Omar is like 83 years old, but he showed again that he can still play. He became an everyday player for the Sox mid-way through the year and posted some very nice offensive numbers. His defense, as always, was outstanding as well.

OF- Alexis Rios (CWS)- Rios maybe could have been the starting CF on this team, but his versatility will play well as a reserve. 21 homers, 34 steals and a .282 average, plus he can play great defense.

UT- Ryan Raburn (Det)- Again, versatility is the key here. Raburn can play OF plus 3B and 2B and 1B in a pinch. His bat really took off after a terrible start and when he began to see more playing time. Raburn finished up with a .280 average with 16 home runs and 62 RBI, posting a 119 OPS+.

Like what you see here and want to stay informed on the happenings at MCB? Make sure to follow us on Twitter, friend us on Facebook, or grab our RSS feed.

Next Tigers Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:05at Cleveland IndiansBuy Tickets

Tags: Alex Rios Alexei Ramirez Austin Jackson Carl Pavano Carlos Santana Chicago White Sox Chris Perez Chris Sale Cleveland Indians Delmon Young Detroit Tigers Edwin Jackson Francisco Liriano Jesse Crain Jim Thome Joakim Soria Joe Mauer Jose Valverde Justin Verlander Kansas City Royals Matt Thornton Max Scherzer Miguel Cabrera Minnesota Twins Omar Vizquel Orlando Hudson Paul Konerko Ryan Raburn Shin-Soo Choo Wilson Betemit

  • Chris

    Hmmm… do you think this team could win the AL East?

    • John Parent

      Um, yes. And I didn’t even have room for Morneau. Although he would have replaced Thome, I guess

  • Matt Snyder

    Not too many beefs from me, although I’d give Inge serious consideration at third. I’d give Vizquel’s spot to someone else probably too.

    The Yuniesky Betancourt part is a joke, right? Because he should never ever be considered for any award not named the worst player ever award. Seriously, all AL Central shortstops (including backups) are better than him.

  • John Parent

    Actually no. Betancourt’s offensive numbers are better than any shortstop in the division with the exception of Ramirez and among players who played a minimum of 450 innings (50 games worth)at short, only Ramirez, Ramon Santiago, and JJ Hardy were better defensively according to UZR. Betancourt was well below average, but he was the fourth-best defensive shortstop in the Central.

    If you use a minimum of 400 PA as a shortstop, only Ramirez and A Cabrera had better wOBA than Betancourt, but Yuni had a higher OPS than Cabrera and was a better fielder this year. He also had a BABiP nearly 50 points lower than Cabrera. The fact is that among even semi-regular shortstops, Betancourt was the second-best in the division this year.

    And I feel dirty now for having defended Betancourt. I agree that he’s terrible overall, but this year he was less terrible than the other terrible shortstops in the division. Hardy might have been there or Casilla, but neither played enough to matter all that much.

  • Matt Snyder

    Betancourt, in all likelyhood, was not a better fielder than Cabrera. His UZR numbers came out better, but according to +/- Cabrera was significantly better.

    I understand PA requirements, but here’s a list of AL Central shortstops that piled up better WAR numbers than Yuniesky:
    A. Ramirez 3.2
    J. Hardy 2.4
    R. Santiago 2.0
    J. Peralta 1.4
    N. Punto 1.4
    A. Casilla 1.1
    Y. Betancourt 0.6

    • John Parent

      So we can agree, based on your WAR table, that Cabrera isn’t in the discussion, yes? That leaves (in my mind) only Hardy and Casilla. While Santiago was the best defender (UZR) at short, he didn’t have the playing time at short needed to be considered, I don’t feel. Really, the same can be said of Casilla as he, like Santiago, played a lot of their games at second.

      Hardy played in only 101 games, but his UZR and OPS+ were both better than Betancourt, who played in 151 games. 50 games is a third of the season. I mean we’re splitting hairs here as neither player made the team, but I suppose, now that I’ve dug a bit deeper into the numbers, I will concede that Hardy had a better season, albeit a much shorter one.

      • John Parent

        I would like to be clear here, I was never asserting than Betancourt was a better PLAYER than any of these guys, only that he had a better season than all but Ramirez. Playing time should be factored in. Otherwise, Morneau makes this team easily (he maybe should have anyway).

        Like I said, it’s a moot point becasue I didn’t put Yuni on the squad, but for the sake of discussion…

        Games Played at Short
        Ramirez- 156
        Betancourt- 151
        Hardy- 101
        Santiago- 85
        Punto- 31
        Casilla- 30

        Betancourt played in a third more games than Hardy and almost half a season more than Santiago. Even if you want Peralta thrown in, he played only 46 games at short. No, he wasn’t as good with the glove as any of those guys, but he offensive numbers stack up well against any of them and he played in many more games. I’m not here to debate the merits of WAR, but to me, playing time should be factored in as well. Is 50 games played worth something? I think it should be.

        • Matt Snyder

          WAR is a counting stat, so playing time shouldn’t really matter. It measures what value you gave to you team while you were playing. In fact, the “replacement level” portion of the stat rewards playing time. You do get some positive value just for showing up.

          What if you and I were on a softball team together. I played all ten games, but only came up with six hits. You were only able to make it to five of the ten games, but you mashed 18 hits. Who had the better season? Me becuase I showed up every week, or you because you actually produced?

          • John Parent

            Well, for half a season, I did. But for the other half, you had the better season. There is no way I could have helped the team by not showing up. In five of the ten games, I did absolutely nothing to help anything, I didn’t even keep book. So while I was more productive in total, the team would have had to forfeit if you had taken the same five games off, which makes you more valuable in those games, even if you did nothing as far as production.

            I guess what I’m saying is that the additional playing time you gave the team adds to your value. While some would consider my season much better than your, I would see the difference as being a lot smaller. Perhaps you could still say I had the better year, but only playing in half the games surely has to count against me.

            Maybe, had I played in the other five games, I would have made 10 errors and cost a boatload of runs. We can assume I wouldn’t, but we don’t know I wouldn’t. We know what you did in 10 games because you played in them, it was recorded. Any projections on what kind of season I WOULD HAVE HAD are just that, projections.

          • Chris

            This whole Betancourt debate really speaks volumes about the management of the Kansas City Royals. The big argument in Betancourt’s favor is playing time? He isn’t even the best shortstop on his cellar-dwelling team!

  • Andy Sox

    I don’t know about the Yuniesky hatred, I always see the stats “per season” if the guy was better hitter, played more time and had a better overall year defensively… is that not and indicator he became a better player this season?

    • John Parent

      Andy, I think that’s a logical conclusion to draw. Yuni is dealing with a reputation of being a waste of a player (much of that cause by his salary). This season he produced at a higher level than he had in the past, so yes, I would agree that in 2010, Betancourt was a better player than he was previously.

      The question we are debating is whether his season was the second-best in the Central by a shortstop. Which, now that I’ve typed that out, seems a silly thing to debate. This is what happens when MLB decides to take half a week off between series I guess.

  • John Parent

    @Chris- That’s an excellent point. I wonder how Yuni’s year is being viewed by Dayton Moore? You think he’s in line for an extension now? I assume you were referring to Aviles when you said Yuni’s not the best SS on his team, which I’ll agree with, but that brings up a different debate, one which is probably better suited for the guys over at Kings of Kauffman.

  • Zac Snyder

    I see Yunieski Betancourt assuming the title of quintessential replacement level player from Willie Bloomquist.

    • Matt Snyder

      I find it interesting that both players can only hit home runs against the Tigers (and ALWAYS hit home runs against the Tigers).