Oct 3, 2012; Cleveland, OH, USA; Cleveland Indians right fielder Shin-Soo Choo (17) reacts after taking a called strike in the first inning against the Chicago White Sox at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: David Richard-USA TODAY Sports

Trade Central: Indians Do Something Right?


This is hard for me to say. Not because I have trouble admitting when an American League Central team makes a good move. I try to give credit where it is due. It’s hard for me to say, because I never thought the Cleveland Indians would do something smart again with their current leadership in place. That may be harsh, but the Indians have been floating in this sea of uncertainty since their trade for Ubaldo Jimenez down the stretch of the 2011 season. That mistake in believing they were a legitimate contender has left Cleveland with a poor farm system, and a poor major league club.

But, I give credit where credit is due.

Today, the Indians and their GM Chris Antonetti did something right. They realized that they had a trade chip in veteran outfielder in Shin- Soo Choo, and they used it to good effect. In a three team deal with the Reds and Diamondbacks, Cleveland acquired outfielder Drew Stubbs and pitching prospect Trevor Bauer. They also added two bullpen arms in Matt Albers and Bryan Shaw. Cleveland also gave up  infielder Jason Donald, reliever Tony Sipp and minor leaguer Lars Anderson in the deal, who landed with the Diamondbacks, the losers in the deal.

This is a step in a positive direction for the Indians and their fans. It means they are looking towards the future because they understand it’s difficult to compete in the present. Detroit, and now Kansas City look to be the two best teams in the division.

While I absolutely love Choo as a player, the Indians added quite a bit of upside here. Bauer, who has big time potential, could be an anchor in the Cleveland rotation for years to come, despite his struggles in his short time in the big leagues. Stubbs, despite having awful plate discipline, still has quality tools. He runs well, and defends at an above average level as well. He also will show power from time to time. His approach is obviously awful, but there is enough talent there to hope for a bit of a bounce back after a rough 2012.

That isn’t even to mention the two bullpen arms in Albers and Shaw that will compete for roster spots in the pen.

Asdrubal Cabrera should be next. Then maybe Chris Perez as well. We will see if Antonelli and company continue to do the right thing.

 

Next Tigers Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Sep 33 Sep7:05at Cleveland IndiansBuy Tickets

Tags: Cleveland Indians Detroit Tigers

  • Damian56xx

    All else considered, don’t we Tigers’ fans want the rest of the ballclub’s division rivals to do the wrong things instead?

    • John Verburg

      Of course. I was assuming this off-season that would continue for Cleveland, since doing the wrong thing is a habit of theirs.I’m kind of shocked it appears they made a good deal.

  • chrisHannum

    I’m not sure that this makes the Indians worse in 2012, though it is obviously supposed to boost them for 2014 and beyond. Those are all major leaguers that they got their hands on and if they can “fix” Stubbs, they definitely win the deal. This is like the Granderson deal, but obviously with a still undetermined outcome. Don’t be surprised if they follow it up by adding guys, not by dealing them away.