Willis and Robertson Making for Tough Decisions

With under three weeks to go in camp, the Tigers have some big decisions looming on the horizon. Most of the roster is set, barring injury of course, but a few slots remain unfilled. Notable among them is the battle for the final two rotation spots.

Lefties Nate Robertson and Dontrelle Willis continue to make strong cases for their inclusion on this team. While both players have hefty contracts, each is in the final year of his deal and speculation has been rampant that the Tigers would release one or both or them should they fail to impress in Lakeland. You could include right hander Jeremy Bonderman in that group as well, but from where I sit, Bondo is all but assured of being the team’s number four guy.

With the sudden and surprising (albeit a pleasant one) demotion of Armando Galarraga yesterday, manager Jim Leyland is now down to three pitchers for one spot in the rotation, with the increasing possibility of one more making the club as a reliever. Earlier in camp, Leyland stressed that none of the starters in camp were guaranteed a bullpen spot should they fail to win a job in the rotation, but as the end of camp draws near, the likelihood increases that one of the two failed starters will wind up in the ‘pen.

If you were laying odds on the five pitchers doing battle for two open spots three weeks ago, Bonderman surely would have been a favorite, followed by Galarraga, Robertson, Eddie Bonine, and Willis -the longest of long shots.

Since then, Galarraga has pitched his way to Toledo while Bonderman has done nothing to lose the job. The remarkable thing is now three weeks later, Willis has actually worked his way into the conversation. A guy that was only in the big league camp because of his contract is showing anyone watching that he is a capable pitcher. It’s been a long time since that was the case.

If you were to rank the potential starters odd again today, it’s likely the order would now be Bonderman as the four and Willis and Robertson in a dead heat for the final spot. While Bonine hasn’t been bad at all, the efforts of the two lefties have passed him by. Anything short of a catastrophic meltdown by either southpaw will keep Bonine out of the rotation.

Of course, Bonine could still make the club as a long man, just as he did a year ago, but he has competition there too. Considering how well Robertson and Willis have pitched thus far, it has gone from a long shot that both would make the team, to almost a probability.

If both lefties continue to get results, Bonine ends up back in Toledo, thanks to his remaining minor league option year. The loser of the starting battle then ends up in the ‘pen as the long reliever. Based solely on past experience, Willis would likely be the starter with Robertson working in relief, waiting for an opportunity to start again.

So what do you think? If the season began today who would make the club as the number five starter and who would be the long man?

Who Makes the Club?

  • Willis & Robertson - Bonine optioned out (63%, 346 Votes)
  • Bonine & Robertson - Willis released (21%, 112 Votes)
  • Willis & Bonine - Robertson released (11%, 62 Votes)
  • Bonine only - Willis & Robertson released (5%, 25 Votes)

Total Voters: 545

Loading ... Loading ...

Next Tigers Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Sep 33 Sep7:05at Cleveland IndiansBuy Tickets

Tags: Dontrelle Willis Eddie Bonine Nate Robertson

  • Bob

    Kornacki over at mlive has Willis pretty much penciled in as one of the starters and Henning wrote a column today saying that he’s on the cusp of being released because he’s lost his zip! How about that for opposing views!

    • http://motorcitybengals.com John Parent

      funny you should mention the Henning article, Bob, I was just about to tear into a response on that one. Check back in a couple hours and I’ll have one up.

  • SportsFan7777

    Bonderman would not make the rotation
    of any contender in MLB.
    He had one lucky year in ’06 and has been lousy
    before and after. Bonderman is a 2 pitch pitcher
    with little or no movement on his fastball.
    Send Bonderman and Zumaya to AAA Toledo to learn
    how to pitch
    OR just concede the Division right now to
    the Twins and/or White Sox

  • SportsFan7777

    Send Bonderman to AAA Toledo.
    He stinks and cannot pitch
    (one lucky year in ’06 and garbage
    before and after).
    Bonderman and Zumaya belong in AAA.
    Keep those 2 on team and Tigers just
    conceded the Division to Twins
    and White Sox.

    • http://motorcitybengals.com John Parent

      The problem with your argument is that Bonderman has more than 5 years of ML service time, so he cannot be sent down without his permission. I can’t see any way he’d okay that move, so the Tigers either have to keep him on the big club or release him. The brass seems to think he’s the missing piece, so I doubt he’s a candidate to be cut. Zumaya could be optioned out, and if he continues to get knocked around the way he has, I don’t think that is out of the question. But if he is sent down, who would you have replace him on the roster?