Miguel Cabrera's Swing Should Be Just Fine After Home Run Derby


Source: YardBarker.com

For better or worse, the Home Run Derby conjures up plenty of opinions. Some view it as harmless fun while others view it as a pointless spectacle. One Detroit sports radio host even went as far as saying it is a proven fact that the home run derby messes with player’s swing. It would be one thing to put the supposed ill-effects of home run derby participation on par with the Madden Curse or the SI cover jinx, but a proven fact? Such a statement might make for good ratings on the radio, but the numbers do not back it up.
(Get Nerdy after the jump!)

When I first started looking for evidence that competing in a home run derby could lead poor second half performance I went straight to what I felt would be the most relevant to Miguel Cabrera: his 2006 statistics. Miguel participated in the 2006 derby and hit nine home runs in the first round and six more in the second round before being eliminated with the event’s third highest total. A quick glance at his pre and post-All-Star break numbers did not show me any reason to be concerned about Cabrera’s participation in this year’s home run derby.

Split G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS
1st Half 86 370 311 66 104 25 1 15 61 51 56 .334 .432 .566 .998
2nd Half 72 306 265 46 91 25 1 11 53 35 52 .343 .428 .570 .998
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 7/11/2010.

If you have been a reader of this blog hopefully you have become somewhat versed in wOBA. (If not, thats ok, read this) Essentially, wOBA is an improvement on OPS as a way to measure the totality of a batter’s offensive output. It takes the best of on-base percentage and slugging percentage to create the weighted on-base percentage that may mean more to a baseball fan.  .400 is great, .340 is average, and less than .300 is bad; just like regular on-base percentage. While Cabrera’s OPS in the above table suggests his second half performance was equal to his first half performance, his second half wOBA actually increased by .012.

OK, so Miguel Cabrera is one player that competed one time. That sample size is awfully small and we already know that he is something of a freak of nature. Maybe Cabby is just too good to succumb to the pitfalls of a “regular” All-Star. Wrong again.

With the help of fellow MCB blogger, Matt, we looked at the stats for all home run derby participants in the last five years and compared their post-home run derby numbers with a three year average made up of the year before, year of, and year after their home run derby participation. Five years worth of data compared against three years worth of career averages shows that the derby guys average .004 wOBA points higher after the break and the rate at which they hit home runs increases by just one percent.

With the myth of declining performance following a home run derby busted, it is interesting to point out that the data set shows that 23 players showed at least .001 wOBA point improvement over their three year career average, 1 showed zero difference, and 16 showed some decline. The player with the biggest difference between his three year wOBA and post-home run derby performance was Brandon Inge in 2009. As Tigers fans know, there is a much better explanation for this decline than simply participating in the home run derby: bad knees. Removing Inge from the data set single-handedly increases the set’s second half wOBA from .004 to .006 better than the three year average.

While the numbers suggest a very slight increase in home run derby participant’s second-half performance I would be much more comfortable simply stating that participating in the home run derby does not mess with a player’s swing. Good news Tigers fans, you can sit back, relax and cheer on Miguel Cabrera during Monday night’s event without having to worry that he is somehow harming his future production.

Next Tigers Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:05at Cleveland IndiansBuy Tickets

Tags: Home Run Derby Miguel Cabrera

  • Pingback: Miguel Cabrera’s Swing Should Be Just Fine After Home Run Derby | Baseball Bloggers Alliance

  • http://www.motorcitybengals.com Matt Snyder

    You hear a lot about the Josh Hamiltons and Bobby Abreus, who were much worse after the break, but no one mentioned it when Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, Joe Mauer, or Lance Berkman exploded in the second-half.

  • Chris Zandstra

    “OK, so Miguel Cabrera is one player that competed one time. That sample size is awfully small… ”

    As a fellow engineer I thank you for recognizing the statistics in a sane manor. My #1 pet peeve lately with ESPN is their ability to try and make correlations between things that have no rational relationship using a ridiculously small sample size. I almost yell at the radio when I hear “Of shortstops that have batted 7th in the lineup in the American League central for the last 2 years, 62% have drawn more walks after the all star break” (not an actual quote, but not terribly exaggerated from some of the stuff I’ve heard). Seriously people, stop making these useless correlations in an effort to sound intelligent.