Miguel Cabrera Arrested on DUI Charge


Detroit Tigers first baseman Miguel Cabrera was arrested Wednesday evening in St. Lucie County, Fla when officers spotted a vehicle on the side of the road with smoke coming from the engine compartment. Cabrera, who pulled out a bottle of scotch and began drinking from it while officers were speaking to him, is reported to have had bloodshot eyes and his speech was heavily slurred.

To make matters worse, Cabrera resisted the officers when they asked him to enter the patrol car at one point pushing an officer off of him. He faces two additional misdemeanor charges of resisting arrest without violence.

Cabrera was released just after 7 am today on $1,350 bond.

Cabrera, it’s no secret, has had run-ins with alcohol before. Late in the 2009 season, with the Tigers locked in a very close division race, Cabrera was arrested on domestic violence charges after an altercation with his wife. Cabrera, the night before, had been out with several members of the Chicago White Sox, who were in town to play the Tigers. Detroit wound up losing a one-game playoff to Minnesota and missing the playoffs despite holding a three game lead with three to play. Many fans and media types blamed Cabrera for the Tigers inability to win even one of those games from Chicago.

In the offseason that followed, Cabrera sought counselling for his alcohol problems and by all accounts came into camp in 2010 a changed man. There were no reports of Cabrera straying from his new path throughout last season and his numbers moved from very impressive to among the absolute elite of offensive performers.

I think we were all hoping that the issues and demons that had plagued him in the past had been defeated, but alcoholism rarely goes away so easily.

There seems to be some of this story that we don’t know. Cabrera is quoted in the above story as saying “I’m going to (effing) kill him” when officers approached, but no one else was in the vehicle, a 2005 Land Rover. Apparently, there might have been someone else in the vehicle who fled before the police arrived. Again, I don’t know that, but from the quotes given it can be inferred. But whether or not Cabrera was actually driving is almost immaterial to this story. Cabrera has obviously relapsed into his alcoholism and how he handles the coming days, weeks, and months will be paramount to his personal recovery and also to the Tigers chances in 2011.

I think it’s important to not overreact to this situation. Rangers slugger Josh Hamilton, famous as much for his substance abuse filled past as his 2010 AL MVP award, also “fell off the wagon” after turning his life around. It’s not unreasonable to think that with a solid support system, Cabrera can regain his sobriety. A lesson can surely be learned today for Cabrera personally. Even if you think you’ve beaten it, you cannot slip, even for a second.

That might be giving Cabrera too much credit, I suppose. I am assuming that this is the first time Cabrera turned back to the bottle, but in reality I have no idea. Perhaps this is simply the first time that we’ve heard about. It’s possible that he’s been drinking the whole time, though I doubt it given Cabrera’s other-worldy performances of 2010 on the baseball field.

Regardless of whether this is his first time off the wagon or not, the point remains that obviously Cabrera is a young man who needs to find help in order to remain sober. Given the value of his contract, I’m certain the Tigers will be happy to help him find that support system.

Stay tuned for updates as we learn more about this situation. This is obviously a piece I had no desire to ever have to write. Here’s hoping for the best possible outcome for Cabrera and his family.

UPDATE: Here’s a copy of the arrest report. It’s not fun reading.

Like what you see here and want to stay informed on the happenings at MCB? Make sure to follow us on Twitter, friend us on Facebook, or grab our RSS feed.

Tags: Arrest Report Arrested Detroit Tigers DUI Miguel Cabrera

  • Sally Chandler

    Are you kidding me? Just when we think we finally have all of the pieces in place and that Miguel Cabrera has LEARNED his lesson?

    • http://sidelionreport.com/ Zac Snyder

      Person first, Player second.

      I keep reminding myself of this. I am disappointed as a fan for what this could do to the team but let’s not pretend that supersedes the potential devastating impacts on the man’s life and his family.

      • http://motorcitybengals.com John Parent

        I think that’s an important point Zac. I am not even thinking about how this affects the team. Baseball is purely (and distantly) secondary at this point. Cabrera needs help as a person, a husband, and a father first.

  • http://tigersamateuranalysis.blogspot.com Erin

    I think you make several good points and I would probably say a lot of the same things. Alcoholism is a disease and while I don’t have an exact figure, I do know the relapse rate is really high. This incident unfortunately makes Cabrera the rule and not the exception. Like you, I am going to withhold judgment until after we get more information. However, as you said, the important thing is that Cabrera learns from this and continues to seek help for this problem, for the team’s sake, his family’s sake, and especially his own sake.

  • Sally Chandler

    A BIG problem is that we treat celebrities and superstar athletes with kid gloves, and differently than you and I. I grew up with a father who was an alcoholic, and as a result, I do not drink at all….I know all too well about alcoholism and its affects on the family. Rather than give him another slap on the wrist and a stint in celebrity rehab, he needs to realize the consequences of his actions and pay the price, whatever that is. He’s got to LEARN the lesson~

    • http://motorcitybengals.com John Parent

      Agreed Sally. This isn’t about his career, it’s about his life and more importantly the lives of his family members. I think there is probably a “it won’t happen to me” feeling at play with Cabrera, but it HAS happened, twice now. It’s time to take control of your life, young man.

  • Bob

    Very depressing. It’s time for Miguel to man up and take responsibility for his life and career. The descent from the top to the abyss is a long and painful one, and I hope he can stop the decline before it’s too late.

  • jayrc

    Terible news

    I’m sure with the help of friends and family Cabby will work through this problem of his.

    It is a bad decision and may be a serious disease. Im quite disgusted with the negative comments from “fans” though. While I’m not condoning his behavior, he is a human being. I’ve worked in the corrections field of law enforcement for almost eight years and I’ve seen sooo many people battle this problem. People that you would never guess in a million years wouldn’t be able to tackle the sauce, drugs etc.

    Rather than rant and rave about his poor choices or disease or whatever you want to call it, we need to support him. It sounds corny but it’s so true. While only he can beat it and his immediate family and teammates can help help him directly… he needs support, not hateful rage from us fans.

    No one is perfect!

    Get better Cabby!