Oct 19, 2013; Boston, MA, USA; Boston Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia (right) tags out Detroit Tigers designated hitter Victor Martinez (left) during the sixth inning in game six of the American League Championship Series playoff baseball game at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: Greg M. Cooper-USA TODAY Sports

Victor Martinez Should Bat Third

The Detroit Tigers have a handful of glaring deficiencies going into the 2014 season that perhaps haven’t gotten the attention that they deserved (and that may be because they’re hard to “fix”). I’ll be looking into these in more detail over the remainder of the offseason – the first of the lot is Victor Martinez‘ legs. If you watched the Tigers play at all last year (or watched Martinez at any point during the past decade) you know that the man is slow. He doesn’t get good jumps, he doesn’t accelerate and he doesn’t really build up much in the way of speed on the basepaths – at least compared to other athletes.

I wouldn’t go so far as to say that Martinez’ speed negates the value of his bat, but it certainly does reduce it. It, of course, is NOT an issue of stealing bases – DHs, first basemen, catchers, these guys rarely have the build required for that. He gets fewer doubles and triples than he otherwise would – if he had the speed of (for example) Alex Avila. He’s less likely to be able to advance on a sacrifice, less likely to go first to third on a single and critically less likely to score from second base. Add it all together – like Fangraphs attempts to do with their BsR metric – and the effect is sizable. According to Fangraphs, -8.2 runs relative to an average DH. Those sorts of calculations are deliberately context-independent, but I’m sure if you dig deep you can recall at least that many runs that VMart appeared to cost the team with his inability to properly run.

The question is “what do you do with a guy that can’t run?” and the first, obvious answer is to get the damn guy in better condition. He does not, after all, need to run like a center fielder – it would mark an 8 run improvement if he could run like an average designated hitter. The second, less obvious answer is to be careful where you bat him in the order. At this point in his career, Martinez’ strongest tool is making contact – the power numbers are considerably down. He isn’t taking quite as many walks as he did in his youth, but the low K% combined with lots of hard-hit grounders and balls in the gaps leads to a high batting average and a very solid OBP. A lot of the time you would assume that a guy that doesn’t run well should be relied upon to drive runners in and there is obviously something to that. The issue is that VMart doesn’t hit a lot of homers anymore, so you’d like him to be in situations where he can drive in guys with singles and doubles. You’d also like to minimize, if possible, the risk of the double play since Martinez isn’t helping any there (and grounded into 23 last season).

What this is leading up to is this: Martinez can be an RBI guy, but Miguel Cabrera probably isn’t the guy that he should be driving in. Cabrera is a fantastic hitter, but in addition to the homers and doubles Cabrera actually singles A LOT and draws more walks than anyone else on the team. VMart – without much home run power – isn’t going to be able to drive him in from first base, and maybe not even from second with Cabrera’s speed. Put him in front of a speedier guy and you’ll see all those singles and doubles leading to sprints around the bases. If it’s a base-stealer that you have, with his high contact rate and selectivity Martinez is the ideal guy to have in the batters’ box.

Of course, Martinez is also arguably the Tigers’ second best “on base threat” after Cabrera himself and despite his struggles in going first-to-third it would make a big difference if the Tigers could bring him around more often. Despite putting up a .301 batting average and playing 159 games, Martinez managed a measly 68 runs scored in 2013. Sadly the only good way to ensure that a guy with legs like Martinez’ crosses home plate is to pound the ball over the fence and after trading Prince Fielder the Tigers are left with exactly one genuine home run threat – Miguel Cabrera. It stands to reason that Martinez’ value will be maximized not by hitting behind Miguel Cabrera and in front of Alex Avila but by batting 3rd in front of Miguel Cabrera and behind someone fleeter of foot, like Andy Dirks, Rajai Davis or Ian Kinsler.

Next Tigers Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:05at Cleveland IndiansBuy Tickets

Tags: Detroit Tigers

  • http://www.LambertKlein.com Lambert Klein

    Miggy would get walked a lot more that way with no protection behind him.

    • chrisHannum

      Torii Hunter hardly qualifies as “no protection” – he actually hit a little better than Martinez did last season (overall). As for the walks, I’d argue that no degree of lineup protection is going to prevent Cabrera from being pitched around if first base is open – simply because hitters of his caliber are so rare. The best way to prevent it might be to make it more likely that walking Cabrera moves somebody else into scoring position.

      • Yuma 3:10

        That last sentence is a great point Chris. Great point.

    • Damus Fucious

      Hunter hitting in either 3-4-5- last season would have netted Torii 100+ ribbies.
      I have been a promoter of Martinez hitting 3rd all winter. He was the best hitter in the AL in the 2nd half of 2013. He needs to get plate appearances galore.

  • Yuma 3:10

    I gave this idea some thought when the Fielder trade occurred. Torii Hunter would provide “some” Protection behind Miggy, but this is taking an awful chance if they do this. I understand the writers logic…just not sure its the right move.

    • chrisHannum

      Given how Cabrera hit in 2012-2013, wasn’t the “awful chance” dealing Fielder? Even in a terrible year (by his standards) Fielder outslugged Martinez.

  • http://tomaroonandgold.blogspot.com Matt Snyder

    I think I might prefer V-Mart in the leadoff spot to reduce his GIDP potential.

    • chrisHannum

      That’s Brilliant!

  • Yuma 3:10

    Chris, I agree that trading Fielder was a gamble…my earlier point was based on what they currently have…and that’s a middle of the order minus the Prince. I still think V Mart in the 4th spot protecting Miggy isn’t a bad thing ( see 2011 ), they key may be in the # 1 and # 2 holes in the order being on base a lot…so that whether it’s Miggy or V Mart…runs are going to come in.

    And just a foot note…and this is just my opinion. On days when Rajai Davis plays, I do not feel he should bat # 2. Reason is, from what i have seen under JL ( could change under Asmus ), is Miggy doesn’t have people in motion on the bases very often when hes at the plate. If Asmus can use Rajai properly, I really want to see him use his speed at every opportunity. I would however like to see Dirks in the 2 hole when he faces RHP. He has historically ( over 3 seasons ) preformed much better when hitting atop the line up.

    • chrisHannum

      Against lefties, I don’t see why Rajai Davis wouldn’t lead off… do you? Jackson – puzzlingly – hasn’t hit the ball with much authority against lefties over the past 4 seasons. I can only suppose that he can really struggle with his timing when they throw a lot of changeups. Kinsler would be a great #2 against lefties, in my opinion. I completely agree with regards to Dirks, he has been better as a table-setter than as a run-producer.

      • http://tomaroonandgold.blogspot.com Matt Snyder

        I would have a hard time projecting Davis’ OBP vLHP to be better than Jackson’s, even given Jackson’s apparent reverse-platoon split. Basically, I’d bet on Jackson outstripping his career split and Davis not living up to his.

        • chrisHannum

          And you could certainly be right, particularly given their respective ages. Davis is the one who knows how to steal, however…