Detroit Tigers: Assessing Team’s Center Field Options

Detroit Tigers general manager Al Avila is instituting change this offseason, as the Tigers look to shed payroll. Seeing as Avila already dealt  Cameron Maybin to save cash, here are Detroit’s center field options.

Detroit Tigers fans will see a different center fielder come Opening Day. With Cameron Maybin now a Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim player, the Tigers are in need of a replacement.

That won’t be an easy task, considering Maybin posted the fourth-highest WAR on the team, with a 2.0 mark that surpassed that of Nick Castellanos, J.D. Martinez, Justin Upton and Victor Martinez.

What’s more, the now-former Tiger turned in a stellar .383 on-base percentage while contributing a 120 wRC+.

Overall, the center fielder hit .315 with a .418 slugging percentage. Maybin also added 65 runs scored, 43 RBI, 15 stolen bases, 14 doubles, five triples and four home runs. His OPS sat at .801.

Outside of the ex-Marlin, Tigers center fielders combined for a WAR of 0.1.

While Maybin didn’t post the most eye-catching defensive numbers from a defensive standpoint, his ability to cover significant ground certainly made an impact in Detroit.

Here’s a breakdown of the Detroit Tigers options to replace Cameron Maybin in center field.

Tyler Collins

Age: 26
Bats: Left-Handed

After appearing in 18 games in 2014, Tyler Collins has seen somewhat consistent work as a fourth outfielder for the Tigers, appearing in 116 games since the beginning of the 2015 campaign.

Collins saw action in 56 contests this past season, batting .235 with a .305 on-base percentage. He also added 15 RBI, 14 runs scored, four home runs, three triples, two doubles and a stolen base in 136 at-bats.

The outfielder also turned in a 0.1 WAR, a 84 wRC+ and a .147 ISO.

Why He’ll Start in Center Field for the Detroit Tigers

Despite posting overall numbers that don’t exactly jump off the page, Collins has flashed potential before, largely in stints at the end of the past two seasons. From September 1^st, 2015 through the end of the 2015 campaign, the outfielder hit .293 with a .376 on-base percentage.

Additionally, over the 2016 season’s final 16 contests, the former sixth-round pick batted .303 with a .400 on-base percentage.

Obviously if Collins can bat .300 over an entire season, the Tigers will benefit. However, if the outfielder can hit anywhere in the .260 or .270 neighborhood, he stands a good chance to see extended playing time.

There’s also the fact that the 26-year-old bats left-handed, which could come in handy considering Detroit’s lineup is comprised mostly of right-handed batters.

Why He Won’t Start in Center Field for the Detroit Tigers

A corner outfielder by trade, Collins saw his first extended action in center field last season.

While his numbers weren’t the best (-4 DRS, -11.4 UZR/150) they don’t seem as poor when you consider that before the year Collins had only played 33 games at the position in his professional career.

Still, if those numbers don’t improve, Detroit won’t want to carry a poor-fielding center fielder throughout the course of next season.

Anthony Gose

Age: 26
Bats: Left-Handed

It’s probably safe to say that Anthony Gose struggled at the plate in his fifth season in the Majors.

The outfielder batted just .209 in 30 games for Detroit, posting a sub-par .287 on-base percentage along the way. In addition, the speedy outfielder didn’t steal any bases, while crossing home just 11 times.

All told, Gose two home runs, two triples and two doubles. Despite hitting in a potent Tigers lineup, the veteran collected just seven RBI.

The former top prospect would go onto appear in 90 games split between Triple-A and Double-A following a demotion from the Majors.

Over those contests, he hit just .224 with a .301 on-base percentage and 21 extra-base hits.

Why He’ll Start in Center Field for the Detroit Tigers

Outside of Jones, Gose is Detroit’s best internal option in terms of adding much-needed speed to the lineup.

The 26-year-old previously swiped 23 bases for the Tigers in 2015, and has stolen at least 70 bases twice in a season in his minor league career.

Like Collins, the fact that he hits from the left side will help add some balance to Detroit’s lineup.

Why He Won’t Start in Center Field for the Detroit Tigers

Despite the speed and some quietly solid defense last year (1.3 UZR, 7.0 UZR/150), Gose simply struggled at the plate.

A return to the form he showed in 2015, when he hit .254 with a .321 on-base percentage, could help him carve out more at-bats.

After an offseason that could conceivably see one or more of J.D. Martinez, Ian Kinsler or Victor Martinez dealt, Detroit can’t afford to field a .200 batter anywhere in the team’s lineup. They’ll potentially be losing enough fire power as it is.

Other Internal Options

Justin Upton

Upton probably won’t see too much playing time in center field, but the Tigers could deploy him there for 10 or 15 games in order to free up occasional at-bats for Steven Moya or another corner outfielder.

Andrew Romine

In 130.2 defensive innings as a center fielder, Romine quietly turned in a 1.3 UZR and a 10.2 UZR/150. Both of those numbers led Tigers center fielders last season.

However, Romine’s defensive flexibility will likely provide more value in his usual utility role.

Mike Gerber

A relative long shot given that Gerber just reached Double-A for the first time last season. However, crazier things have happened.

It’s also hard to ignore the prospect’s production so far. In just three minor league seasons, Gerber has stuffed the stat sheet with 198 RBI, 187 runs scored, 80 doubles, 38 home runs, 33 stolen bases and 20 triples.

In 132 games split between Lakeland and Erie, the outfielder batted .276 with a .345 on-base percentage. He also added 80 RBI, 69 runs scored, 30 doubles, 18 home runs, eight stolen bases and six triples.

Connor Harrell

Another long shot, Harrell completed his second season at Erie in 2016. The former seventh-round pick hit .273 with a .340 on-base percentage.

The 6’3” outfielder also added 60 runs scored, 32 RBI, 17 doubles, 10 home runs and six stolen bases.

Potential Free Agent Fits

Given the Detroit Tigers current goal to shed money, the team is unlikely to sign top free agent options like Ian Desmond or Dexter Fowler. This probably also means players like Jon Jay and Rajai Davis are out of Detroit’s price range.

Still, there’s some potential depth options on the market who could appeal to the Tigers.

Dustin Ackley

The first player selected after Stephen Strasburg in the 2009 draft, Ackley initially showed promise with Seattle as a rookie. In 90 games with the M’s, Ackley hit .273 while posting 36 RBI, 16 doubles, seven triples, six home runs and six stolen bases.

He hasn’t been able to replicate similar numbers since, but could turn things around in Detroit.

Michael Bourn

While he isn’t a threat to post stolen base totals that push 70 anymore, Bourn can still contribute on the base paths. In 113 game split between Arizona and Baltimore, the veteran turned in a 3.0 BsR and 15 steals.

He’d help replace Maybin’s speed in the Motor City.

Austin Jackson

Old friend Austin Jackson could be the perfect fit for the Tigers considering his skillset and past production in Detroit.

The 29-year-old is a prime bounce-back candidate after registering just 18 RB and 14 extra-base hits—not to mention a .661 OPS—in 54 games for the White Sox.

Desmond Jennings

Jennings is an obvious fit in Detroit as a bounce-back candidate given blend of speed and pop.

However, like Gose he’ll need to improve his batting splits. In 65 games for the Rays last season, Jennings batted just .200. His on-base percentage ended up at .281.

Next: Pros and Cons of Trading V-Mart This Offseason

Other potential free agent options include Peter Bourjos, Justin Ruggiano, Drew Stubbs, Sam Fuld, Logan Schafer and former Tiger Alex Presley.