AL Wild Card (and division) standings really make Tigers' disappointing 2026 season even worse

This season has been an unmitigated disappointment for the Detroit Tigers. Full stop. Their current record of 64-75 is a far cry from where they expected to be at the beginning of the season, and examining what it would have taken for them to be in the playoffs only makes matters worse.

Entering play on Saturday, the Chicago White Sox led the American League Central with a record of 74-67. Before the Cleveland Guardians' doubleheader beatdown of the Tigers, the White Sox were only team in the division above .500 on the year. That would’ve been unthinkable back in March, but that’s just the beauty (or ugliness) of baseball.

The AL Wild Card standings are even more upsetting as the Guardians currently have the third Wild Card spot with a record of 72-70. The Tigers are 7.5 games back so there’s a non-zero chance they could go on a run and sneak into the Wild Card, but realistically they are out of playoff contention and have no one to blame but themselves.

If one had run the season on a simulation at the start of the year, the Tigers would probably be leading the division right now, comfortably. Their pitching staff looked like one of the best in MLB and the offense looked pretty good on paper too — at least good enough to be average.

That’s not a bad combination, but it didn’t take long for things to fall apart. The pitching staff got banged up and the bullpen was not as strong as everyone thought it would be, so the team’s strength turned into more of a weakness. The team just couldn’t hold on.

Even when the Tigers went on stretches where they’d play well and look like they could be a legitimate playoff team, they’d royally screw it up somehow. Tarik Skubal’s final start as a Tiger this year really sums it up. He left the game with a sizable lead, but the bullpen coughed it up and Detroit decided to sell at the trade deadline.

2026 was the perfect year for the Tigers to make a run

Maybe if they held on in that game and built some momentum, they would have kept Skubal and Casey Mize, made a trade for an outfielder and a bullpen arm, and could be right around .500 with a legitimate shot at the playoffs.

But they are now sliding further and further out of the picture, which has to be so frustrating for Tigers fans because of how weak the American League is this year. None of the AL's teams look incredibly scary, so if the Tigers could have just made it to the dance with Skubal and Mize atop the rotation, they could’ve made an October run.

Alas, it just wasn’t meant to be. Now, barring an historic comeback, they will end this season thinking about what could have been, had things gone just a little bit differently.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow