Skip to main content

Dodgers GM's River Ryan comparison increases Tigers hype (but also feels like a warning)

Little bit of column A, little bit of column B.
ByConnor Muldowney
Sep 21, 2026; Detroit, Michigan, USA;  Detroit Tigers pitcher River Ryan pitches in the first inning against the Washington Nationals at Comerica Park.  Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images
Sep 21, 2026; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Detroit Tigers pitcher River Ryan pitches in the first inning against the Washington Nationals at Comerica Park. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Tarik Skubal trade may be in the rearview mirror, but the other pieces involved — Zyhir Hope, River Ryan, and Brady Smith — in the deal will be monitored for as long as they’re in the Tigers’ system because that’s the only way to really judge if Detroit won the deal.

Skubal’s half-season stint in LA resulted in the Dodgers being bounced before the World Series, so he didn’t even get his wish after being dealt from the organization he called home for his entire MLB career.

The Tigers’ return, on the other hand, was headlined by a top-25 MLB prospect in Hope and supplemented with No. 68 prospect Ryan (No. 7 in the Dodgers’ system) and the Dodgers’ No. 17 prospect (Smith).

On paper, the deal seemed lopsided considering Skubal was the best pitcher on the planet at the time, but it’s since leveled out as Hope got comfortable in the minors and Ryan actually made two starts at the end of the year for Detroit, pitching a total of 4 1/3 innings with a 4.15 ERA. He had six strikeouts and three walks — so he was kind of all over the place.

Ryan clearly has some juice as a starter and Dodgers general manager Brandon Gomes had a really nice comparison for him that should make Tigers fans pretty happy.

A young Walker Buehler was one of the best pitchers in baseball for a four-year stretch before undergoing Tommy John surgery.

This is a nice comparison if he’s talking about pre-injury Buehler, but Ryan, too, has had Tommy John surgery and hasn’t quite looked the same since.

This comparison feels like it could be a compliment with a warning attached.

Ryan has plenty of talent and being compared to Buehler feels like a good sign, but it could also mean that he’s just a really talented starting pitcher who’s always going to struggle with injuries. Buehler was one of the Dodgers’ best pitchers — and one of the best in baseball — from 2018-2021 until he had to undergo Tommy John surgery in 2022 after pitching in 12 games.

Buehler never looked the same after that, pitching through lingering soreness in 2024 and 2025 with the Dodgers and Red Sox with an ERA north of 5.00. He finally felt healthier in 2026, but he’s clearly not the same pitcher he once was.

If the Dodgers’ general manager is comparing Ryan to his former pitcher because he’s as good as pre-injury Buehler, that’s a good sign for the Tigers. If he means he’s good but he’s always hurt, that’s a not-so-good sign.

This intriguing comparison seems to be coming with a warning.

River Ryan’s injury concerns are real

There’s a reason that a talented 28-year-old starter has only had two stints in the big leagues despite being drafted all the way back in 2021: injuries.

He shook off an injury to at least finish the season, but those concerns still linger.

In 2024, he had Tommy John surgery and was forced to miss the entire 2025 campaign. This really put a damper on the hot start that he got off to in 2024, posting a 1.33 ERA over four starts and 20 1/3 innings with the Dodgers. He looked like a young star in the making, but the injury dampened his outlook with the organization.

Log Angeles was seemingly sick of waiting around for him to get comfortable and get that arm back to full health so he was included in the Skubal trade despite looking like a young Buehler, per Gomes. He was also dealing with some hamstring strains early in the 2026 season so that probably made Gomes’ and president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman's decision to deal him easier.

Ryan has the talent and he’s proven that he can hang in the majors, but the Buehler comp feels a lot more like a “he’s really good, but” situation.

For the Tigers’ sake, hopefully he can remain healthy and be 2018-2021 Walker Buehler and now post-2022 Walker Buehler.

Add us as a preferred source on Google