Keider Montero starting Tigers' spring training opener is first test in make-or-break year

When the Detroit Tigers hand the ball to Keider Montero for Saturday’s Grapefruit League opener against the New York Yankees, it isn’t just about getting innings in February. It’s about evaluating where one of the organization’s most intriguing — and most complicated — pitchers fits into a roster that suddenly has championship expectations.

Two seasons ago, Montero looked like a fast-rising fixture. He delivered a strong rookie campaign in 2024, pitched meaningful postseason innings, and showed enough poise to earn the trust of manager A. J. Hinch in October situations — the kind of confidence organizations don’t hand out lightly.

But instead of settling into a defined role in 2025, Montero became the embodiment of modern roster flexibility. He shuttled back and forth between Detroit and Triple-A Toledo four separate times, bouncing between starting assignments, bullpen work and emergency coverage.

The numbers reflected the chaos of Montero's 2025 season. A 4.37 ERA across 20 appearances with Detroit told only part of the story. As a starter, he flashed legitimate promise with a 3.72 ERA. Out of the bullpen, the results were uneven. But when the season was on the line, he came up big once again.

Montero delivered a seven-strikeout performance in a Wild Card-clinching win at Boston and once again earned postseason trust. In the ALDS against Seattle, he earned a Game 1 save, recorded multiple scoreless outings, and displayed extra-inning composure that kept elimination at bay.

Now, Montero enters a pressure-packed spring training with a chance to become the Tigers’ ultimate pitching weapon — or the odd man out in a rotation suddenly overflowing with ambition.

Keider Montero faces uncertain role after Tigers' aggressive offseason

If Montero hoped stability would finally arrive in 2026, Detroit’s aggressive winter complicated things. The additions of veteran starters Framber Valdez and Justin Verlander transformed the rotation overnight. Suddenly, a staff already anchored by Tarik Skubal, Jack Flaherty and Casey Mize had five established starters locked into Opening Day roles, barring injury.

That pushes Montero somewhere between sixth and seventh on the depth chart. The Tigers believe they can chase a deep October run, and roster spots now come with urgency attached. That makes spring training less about preparation and more about persuasion.

Montero’s path forward might look a lot like his October success. His arsenal changes when he shortens outings, and his four-seam fastball and sinker ticked up into the mid-90s during postseason relief appearances. That extra velocity transformed his already high-spin slider and knuckle-curve into legitimate swing-and-miss weapons.

Modern contenders thrive on pitchers who blur roles — multi-inning relievers, playoff firemen, swingmen who bridge starters to elite closers. Detroit’s bullpen construction increasingly hints they value exactly that type of weapon, and Montero might be uniquely built for it.

Spring openers rarely feel consequential, but this one does for Montero. Saturday's start won't decide his season, but it may help to determine where he fits on a Tigers team trying to win right now.