Kevin McGonigle's tear could force Tigers into decision fans have been waiting for

Detroit Tigers fans have been patiently waiting for the next wave of homegrown talent to arrive. Patience has been the name of the game, but patience only lasts so long when one of your prospects is flat-out tearing through the minor leagues like he has no business being there.

Major League Baseball’s No. 2 overall prospect, shortstop Kevin McGonigle, is a 21-year-old hitting machine who is quickly forcing the Tigers’ hand.

McGonigle hasn’t just been good, he’s been relentless. At Double-A Erie, he’s hitting .294/.393/.618 with 27 RBI and an impressive 18/13 BB/K ratio through 27 games. And he’s doing this while being more than three and a half years younger than the average player in the league.

Tigers’ future star Kevin McGonigle looks too good to keep in minors

This isn’t a one-stop hot streak either. When you zoom out and look at his full season, the numbers have stayed loud. Combine his work at Single-A Lakeland, High-A West Michigan, and now Erie, and McGonigle is sitting on 88 hits and a 1.045 OPS. 

Across his minor league career (164 games total), McGonigle owns a .320 average, .938 OPS, 195 hits, 49 doubles, six triples, and 20 homers. Fourteen of those bombs have come this season, a clear sign that his power is rounding into form. Scouts and fans alike have long believed the bat would play in the majors, but now the power stroke is catching up, and that’s when prospects transform into cornerstone pieces.

If you want a taste of just how advanced McGonigle’s bat has become, look no further than his home run off pitching prospect Jarlin Susana. He turned around a 100.2 mph heater, a feat so rare that only five major league hitters in 2025 have managed to homer off a pitch that fast.

The Tigers do have other exciting names in their pipeline — Max Clark among them — but McGonigle is on another planet right now. And as much as the Tigers may want to carefully manage his development, fans can’t help but feel like the clock is ticking. With every double in the gap, every ball launched into the seats, McGonigle is making the same argument: he’s ready for more.

At this rate, it’s only a matter of time before the Tigers make the move fans have been waiting for. Whether it comes as a late-season promotion to Triple-A or a spot on the 2026 Opening Day roster, one thing is clear: Kevin McGonigle looks ready to kick down the door to the majors.

More Tigers content from Motor City Bengals