The Tigers have yet to make a decisive call about Spencer Torkelson, and it's almost impossible to say exactly where the front office's head is at regarding his future with the team. Their defense of Javy Báez and Kenta Maeda (they'll be platooning Báez at shortstop with Trey Sweeney next season and will give Maeda the chance to compete for a spot in the rotation again) does make it seem like they'll also be hesitant to part ways with Torkelson, but there's also been a conspicuous lack of updates on his status so far.
Insiders seem split on it as well. Tigers beat writer Evan Petzold said that a divorce seemed inevitable, but Jim Bowden, in recommending Giants infielder LaMonte Wade Jr. as a potential trade option for the Tigers, conspicuously used "platoon" to describe a potential situation with both Wade and Torkelson on the roster.
Another first base option the Tigers could acquire via trade is Yandy Díaz, who MLB.com's Mark Feinsand also named as the top first baseman who could be moved this offseason. Petzold also named Díaz as a potential solution for the Tigers earlier this month.
Yandy Díaz could be the perfect solution to Tigers' first base/Spencer Torkelson problem
When Petzold wrote up a mock trade that would send Díaz to Detroit, he listed Casey Mize and No. 11 prospect Troy Melton as the return to Tampa Bay. Díaz is set to make $10 million in 2025 and has a club option worth $12 million for 2026, an absolute steal (typical of the Rays) for a guy who placed sixth in MVP voting last year and led the AL in batting average.
Díaz would also be ideal for the way the Tigers like to configure their infield, with many moving and changeable parts. If the Tigers really aren't willing to part ways with Torkelson, they could platoon him with Díaz, who could then remain a regular fixture of the lineup with turns at third base, if Detroit is willing to play Matt Vierling in the outfield more often.
The Tigers should just cut Torkelson loose altogether — maybe even use him as part of a potential Díaz trade with the Rays? — but if they're going to be stubborn about sticking by a former first overall draft pick, then they at least need reinforcements. Díaz has a lot of what the Tigers need/want: a right-handed bat, some reliable power, and a very affordable contract.