Obscure former Red Sox takes aim at Kevin McGonigle in desperate bid at relevancy

Kevin McGonigle should be the 2026 American League Rookie of the Year. It might not be unanimous, it might even be a little too close with the Guardians' Parker Messick for Tigers fans' comfort, but it's the only right choice for the BBWAA voters to make.

McGonigle ended the season with a 7.1 bWAR, the best in the AL and fourth-best in baseball, and a 5.4 fWAR, fifth among AL position players and best of any MLB rookie.

WAR, no matter who's measuring it, is divisive. The fact that the two statistical powerhouses that cover the sport disagree about how it should be calculated sums that up pretty well. Neither take context into account, and defensive calculations are imperfect at best.

A former journeyman made the curious choice to weigh in on WAR, but made the mistake of dragging McGonigle into the mix. Rangers/Red Sox/Rockies/Blue Jays utility man Jeff Frye, who spent eight seasons in the majors from 1992-2001 but now spends most of his time online, is getting ratio'd on Twitter for trying to insert himself and his long-gone career into the conversation surrounding McGonigle.

In the process, he knd of just made everyone feel bad for how his career shook out.

Former utility man Jeff Frye inserts himself into the Kevin McGonigle conversation

Let's take WAR out of the equation here entirely. Frye played eight major league seasons, hitting a career .290 with a .742 OPS, 16 homers, and 194 RBI. In just one season, McGonigle hit .278 with a .806 OPS, 18 homers, and 72 RBI, on pace to pass Frye in that last metric in less than three seasons. If we want to bring defense into it, Frye spent the vast majority of his innings at second base, a lower-leverage position than either shortstop or third base, where McGonigle spent his rookie season.

So, yes, one year of Kevin McGonigle is more valuable than eight years of Jeff Frye. Sorry, Jeff.

These were dangerous waters for Frye to wade into, given that he was basically telling on himself and inviting the ridicule of any number of Tigers fans who could tell him the exact same thing. Why set yourself up for failure by comparing yourself to a rookie who's already had a better first season than you did a career?

Maybe this is already giving Frye more attention than he deserves, but Tigers fans are already plenty fed up with the McGonigle/Messick debate that's only going to get worse ahead of the actual announcement of the winner. No one needs a forgotten utility man butting into the conversation.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow