Detroit Tigers: 3 former players who have found success elsewhere
These former Tigers have been great for their new teams this season.
It's a tail as old as time. The Detroit Tigers have a player who struggles in Detroit, only to go elsewhere and thrive. It's the third constant in life to go along with death and taxes.
There have been too many to count over the years. Even players that thrived in Tigers uniforms — such as Justin Verlander or Max Scherzer — went on to be better somewhere else.
Today, we're going to go over a few players that played for the Tigers last season, but have found success on new teams this season. All of these players had good moments in their Tigers careers, but were never really consistent.
Here are three former Tigers who have found success elsewhere
1. Jeimer Candelario has been great for the Nationals and Cubs
This is one that people love to have fun with. Candy had a great shortened 2020 season, then went on to put up a 3.9 fWAR and lead the league in doubles in 2021. There were talks of extending him the following offseason, but the Tigers held off, and you could say they made the right choice.
Candelario hit .217 with an 80 wRC+ last year. Both his offense and his defense massively regressed. Because of that, then-new president of baseball operations thought it would be better to part ways.
He signed a one-year deal with the Washington Nationals in the offseason, and got off to a great start with them, slashing .258/.342/.481 with 16 homers. His performance saw him garner significant interest at the trade deadline, and he was eventually traded to the Chicago Cubs — the team that traded him to the Tigers back in 2017.
He has been on a heater ever since coming back to the windy city, hitting .425 with a 1.114 OPS over 45 plate appearances. He's already worth 3.7 fWAR this year. This was a huge prove-it year for him, and he's come through.
Many Tigers fans have been upset with Scott Harris for not retaining Candelario, completely dismissing that fact that he was terrible on both sides of the ball last year. Once more, the problem wasn't letting Candelario walk, it was doing nothing to replace him. Had the Tigers got a legit third baseman instead of the combination of Nick Maton/Zach McKinstry/Andy Ibanez/others, people wouldn't be nearly as upset.
The Tigers could easily bring Candelario back this offseason. He's earned himself a nice paycheck. He can play third, while Colt Keith could be moved over to second base.
Jeimer Candelario is a good person. It's nice to see him have some success. He deserves it.
2. Joe Jimenez has been solid out of the bullpen for the Braves
Joe Jimenez broke out for the Detroit Tigers last year after struggling with consistency his entire career. He was traded to Atlanta at the Winter Meetings for Justyn-Henry Malloy, a trade that could very easily end up working out for both sides.
In 43 IP, Jimenez has a 2.72 ERA, 2.95 FIP, and 11.3 K/9 for the Braves this season. He's pretty much picked up where he left off in 2022.
He still has a tendency to get hit hard, but the biggest issue for him in Detroit was the walks, and Chris Fetter got those to come way down last season. That has continued in Atlanta.
He is also stranding inheritied runners at a much better rate than last season. He's just been a really solid high-leverage reliever for a Braves team that has been unstoppable this season.
It took about five years for Joe Jimenez to become horse of the bullpen he is now. It's unfortunate we only saw this version of him in a Tigers uniform for one season.
3. Gregory Soto has been pretty lights out for the Phillies this season
Gregory Soto was kind of a controversial figure in Detroit. Fans either loved him or hated him. He was like every Tigers closer ever: effectively wild.
It wasn't a surprise to see Harris trade Soto, considering he didn't really fit the "dominate the strike zone" mantra. Soto was traded to the Phillies for Matt Vierling, Nick Maton, and Donny Sands in a trade that continues to not look great for the Tigers. But that's an article for another time.
For Soto, we're going to need you to look past the surface numbers. He has a 4.84 ERA and the lowest K/9 of his career in 44.2 IP. But he also has a 3.13 xERA, 3.81 FIP, and the lowest BB/9 of his career at 3.63. He walked over five batters per nine innings during his career as a Tiger.
Soto has had a few blowup outings, which explains the high ERA, but other than that he's been lights out in Philly. He's really limited the hard contact this year, which was something he struggled mightily with last season.
Would the Tigers bullpen look better with Soto in it? It's hard to say, since Chris Fetter tried everything with him and still couldn't get him to throw strikes with any kind of consistency. We're seeing something similar with Alex Lange right now.
Soto is walking fewer batters and allowling far less hard contact. That has led to one of the best years of his career. It just stinks it didn't come in a Tigers uniform.