1. C Jake Rogers
Who else was going to take the top spot? Jake Rogers has had this mustache since 2021, and it has only gotten better with age.
The main thing that puts Rogers' mustache on top is that's a full-on horseshoe 'stache. Its had time to grow and mature. Plus, now Rogers has shaved the rest of his face, so we can focus solely on that beautiful specimen.
That's just it. It's a glorious mustache. There's really nothing else to say. Jake Rogers has the best mustache on the team.
There are some other great mustaches in baseball. Atlanta's Spencer Strider, Yankees' Nestor Cortes Jr., and former Tiger Andrew Chafin immdiately come to mind. But Jake Rogers' mustache takes the cake for the Detroit Tigers.