The Tigers have moved on from certain holdover strategies over the last few seasons — reckless sends home at third, pitching chaos — but some things never change. For Detroit, that means defensive flexibility everywhere.
Despite letting go of Matt Vierling, the Tigers' infield, from second to third especially, is incredibly fluid and just got restocked with options in Max Anderson and Peyton Graham. Along with the two of them, Kevin McGonigle, Hao-Yu Lee, Colt Keith, Zach McKinstry, and Javy Báez are all options.
And although there was some thinking among Tigers fans that McGonigle's development in particular may be better served by letting him stick to one position, that doesn't look like it's going to happen. If anything, Scott Harris just wants to make him even more flexible.
He listed McGonigle among Detroit's possibilities at second base, a position their Rookie of the Year didn't touch in 2026. That gives the Tigers a lot of depth and a lot of options, which is always good, but if this turns out to be a case of too many cooks in the kitchen, the front office could also have some formidable juice in a future trade.
Tigers opening the door for Kevin McGonigle to play second gives Detroit options
Most of the names on this list are optionable. Either or both of Anderson and Lee can be relegated to Triple-A if necessary, and Graham still needs some time to develop. Báez has become a true superutility player, so he could spend some time in right field along with Ben Malgeri and Kerry Carpenter.
Ideally, the Tigers will end up having a lot of over-performers who will make roster decisions tough on the front office, but it's also fine (and more realistic) if they need to give some of their more disposable players time to breathe at the major league level.
As long as those players don't completely flame out in the majors, it gives Detroit some heavy firepower on the trade market. Trading a couple of the younger infield pieces to get a single, solid veteran back doesn't sound like a bad idea.
It might still be a little unrealistic, given how this front office operates. Harris seems allergic to the idea that he might trade a young player he hasn't even seen much of at the major league level, only for that player to become a star on his new team.
The Tigers will probably continue to tread cautiously, but at least they might have some room to be flexible here.
