The adage of when it rains, it pours can certainly be applied to how the 2026 season has felt for the Detroit Tigers. Not even the arrival of Kevin McGonigle could mask just how miserable the year has felt. A new low was reached in the Tigers' 3-2 loss to the New York Mets on Wednesday night.
The Tigers have lost seven of their last eight games, and in the sixth inning of Wednesday's game, it seemed that their luck had finally turned. Zach McKinstry reached first base on a fielding error by first baseman Mark Vientos. As Jason Benetti put it, it looked as if Vientos was trying to "trap an insect" while trying to secure the ball in his glove, and in doing so, his foot came off the base.
Given how things have gone for the Tigers in recent weeks, that moment felt like the baseball gods were getting ready to right the ship. Finally, luck would fall on the Tigers' side. Unfortunately, it was a fleeting feeling.
Ugliness has defined the Tigers' play this season
Before the next pitch was even thrown, McKinstry got too far off first base and was a fish out of water. McKinstry was thrown after a brief pickle, and the Tigers' 2-1 lead would eventually turn into a Mets' walk-off win in extra innings.
Making matters worse, the Tigers wasted the very thing they needed to see from Framber Valdez, who was making his return from a suspension. Valdez pitched into the seventh inning, striking out seven, while only giving up two runs. That's the version of Valdez the Tigers will need as their pitching staff gets healthy, but the gem was wasted against the Mets.
Needless to say, for a team that couldn't buy a break if Kroger was giving away one for free, fans are starting to reach their breaking point.
If Chris Ilitch truly cares about the City of Detroit like he claims, he’ll make a change tonight. I understand the injuries but the way this team is playing is completely unacceptable at the MLB level.
— 💩 (@playwitit_xo) May 14, 2026
The silver lining for the Tigers continues to be the fact that the division hasn't moved away from them yet. They are still within shouting distance of the Cleveland Guardians in first place, and for everything that has gone wrong, Detroit arguably still has the most talented team in the American League Central.
That being said, talent may not matter if the gaffes like the one McKinstry made on Wednesday night continue. There's no overcoming poor fundamentals, and above all else, that is what needs to change for the Tigers moving forward.
