Tigers better hope hiring former Blue Jays scouting director isn't the wrong move

The Detroit Tigers went on a magical late-season and playoff run in 2024 fueled in large part by their strong farm system. After trading away a number of key veterans at the deadline, they leaned into the youth movement that took them all the way to Game 5 of the ALDS against the Cleveland Guardians. Now, it appears, the Tigers are investing more resources into its farm system to ensure that it remains an organizational strength moving forward.

The Detroit News' Chris McCosky confirmed an original report from Bob Elliott of the Canadian Baseball Network that the Tigers were finalizing a deal to name Shane Farrell their new farm director. Farrell has spent the last five seasons as the Toronto Blue Jays’ director of amateur scouting and was in charge of the team’s drafts. He also has ties to Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris — the two previously worked together in the Chicago Cubs’ front office.

There haven't been any reports of anyone leaving the Tigers front office, so it seems likely that Farrell will take over some of the day-to-day responsibilities of Ryan Garko, who was promoted to Vice President of Player Development earlier this year.

Tigers make misguided hire by importing Blue Jays scouting director

The Tigers' farm system has rapidly improved under Garko in recent years, especially with hitters like Parker Meadows, Wenceel Pérez, Colt Keith and others making tangible adjustments to their mechanics and demonstrating significant improvement as a result.

Meanwhile, the Blue Jays' development pipeline in recent years isn't exactly a ringing endorsement for Farrell. Homegrown talents such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette appear to be exceptions to the rule for a Toronto system that has struggled to develop and produce a consistent pipeline of minor league talent that transitions successfully to MLB.

Admittedly, the Blue Jays' continued struggles down on the farm don't provide great optics for this hire by the Tigers. Granted, Farrell wasn't overseeing the farm system in Toronto like he will be in Detroit, so perhaps we should reserve judgment for now.

Either way, Tigers fans should be hopeful that he's better suited for a player development role in an organization that just dug itself out from the depths. The Tigers suffering from the same systemic problems Farrell faced in Toronto would be a massive setback.

More Tigers content from Motor City Bengals