Tigers could capitalize on non-tendered pitchers to maximize free agency spending

The Detroit Tigers are shaping up to be one of the more frustrating teams during the 2024-25 offseason. They are on the rise after a magical, late-season run in 2024 despite being deadline sellers, but there are still key areas of need on their roster that need to be addressed before next season. And yet, they don't seem particularly inclined to make the necessary financial investment to address those needs.

Assuming the Tigers are taking a cost-conscious approach to free agency spending, we can effectively rule out any of the big-ticket names on the market landing in Detroit this offseason. But last week's non-tender deadline saw a new wave of free agents hit the market – presumably, at more reasonable prices – which gives the Tigers more options as they consider ways to upgrade their roster from last season.

Bleacher Report's Joel Reuter recently ranked several of MLB's newest free agents who were non-tendered at the deadline, and a few names stand out as potential fits for a Tigers team that's not trying to break the bank this offseason. The club's three biggest needs are arguably a corner infielder, a right-handed bat and a starting pitcher, but there are several relievers hitting the market who could also help round out Detroit's pitching staff.

Tigers could capitalize on pool of non-tendered pitchers to maximize free agency spending

The only true starting pitcher who cracked Reuter's rankings was Cal Quantrill, who finished a rather forgettable 2024 campaign with the Colorado Rockies and carried a relatively steep projected arbitration salary of $9 million. Considering Quantrill's National League-leading 69 walks against just 110 strikeouts, the Tigers could best utilize him as a bullpen swingman and nothing more.

This year's notable non-tenders include a handful of high-upside relievers at reasonable asking prices who could provide a boost to the Tigers' pitching staff. Brent Honeywell Jr., for example, is a bulk reliever who revived his career in 2024, posting a 2.62 ERA in 18 appearances to help lift the Los Angeles Dodgers to a World Series title.

Right-hander Jacob Webb could be another solid, low-risk option for the Tigers. Another righty, Kyle Finnegan who could be well worth the risk if he returns to his early-season form after a 2024 season that saw him earn 38 saves and an All-Star selection with the Washington Nationals. That kind of late-inning experience would play extremely well in the Tigers' bullpen alongside closer Jason Foley.

If the Tigers aren't going to spend big in free agency, they need to at least get creative with maximizing their resources. These non-tendered bullpen arms would be a great place to start.

More Tigers content from Motor City Bengals