Tigers fans will feel ambivalent over Red Sox broadcast’s flaming of Framber Valdez

The Detroit Tigers needed Framber Valdez to be the stabilizing force in the middle of a rotation crisis. Instead, he became the story for all the wrong reasons.

By the time the top of the fourth inning rolled around Tuesday night, the Red Sox were already hammering Detroit’s de facto interim ace. Then came the knockout blows: back-to-back home runs from Willson Contreras and Wilyer Abreu that pushed Boston into double digits and proved to be the final straw for Valdez.

What happened next only intensified the scrutiny. Valdez drilled Trevor Story in the back with a 94.4 mph fastball — notably, the first four-seamer he has thrown all season — immediately igniting benches-clearing tension. Valdez later insisted it was unintentional, but almost nobody outside the Tigers clubhouse seemed willing to buy that explanation.

And that’s where Tigers fans may find themselves feeling deeply conflicted. Because the Red Sox broadcast absolutely torched Valdez in real time — and some of the criticism felt impossible to argue against.

“That’s tired... You can’t get him out, so you throw at him. What a joke,” NESN color analyst Will Middlebrooks said on-air.

Play-by-play voice Dave O’Brien added moments later: “That is weak — you give up three home runs, back-to-back shots, and then you drill Trevor Story.”

Middlebrooks piled on, adding: "The one guy who caused it's hiding in the back... Let’s just hope he doesn’t cross up his catcher now that he’s mad.”

That, of course, was a direct shot at Valdez’s infamous 2025 incident in Houston, when he hit Astros catcher César Salazar in the chest immediately after surrendering a grand slam. Valdez denied intent then, too. Almost nobody believed him then, either.

NESN broadcast torched Framber Valdez for plunking Trevor Story, and it's hard even for Tigers fans to argue

Valdez's reputation is now following him to Detroit, and Tigers fans probably understand why Red Sox broadcasters reacted the way they did. If the situation were reversed — if an opposing pitcher with Valdez’s history drilled Riley Greene or Kevin McGonigle after getting shelled — Detroit fans would be furious, too.

But Detroit can’t afford for this to spiral out of control. Tarik Skubal is already sidelined. Justin Verlander remains out. Casey Mize is hurt. The Tigers acquired Valdez specifically for moments like this — to hold the rotation together when everything else started collapsing around it.

Instead, there’s now legitimate concern Detroit could lose him to suspension at the exact moment they need him most.

Which leaves Tigers fans in a strange spot: understanding why Boston blasted Valdez while simultaneously wishing their supposed ace had given everyone far less ammunition to do it.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow