Tigers' first offseason signing imports pitcher who hasn't been in MLB since 2021

With just days left until the Winter Meetings begin, we finally have signs of life from the Detroit Tigers' front office... well, sort of.

The Tigers dipped into the KBO/NPB talent pool, agreeing to a one-year deal with right-hander Drew Anderson, per Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. The deal also has a club option tacked on for 2027. It’s a low-risk move, pending his physical, and one with some surface-level intrigue: Anderson posted a 2.25 ERA across 30 starts last season in Korea. That’s legitimately great production overseas.

According to Cody Stavenhagen of The Athletic, the Tigers expect Anderson to be a starter. But let’s be honest here—if the Tigers want 2026 to be anything other than a repeat of last season, this can’t be anywhere close to the headliner.

Anderson hasn’t touched a Major League mound since 2021, and when he did, the results weren’t exactly glowing. Across parts of four seasons with the Philadelphia Phillies, Texas Rangers and Chicago White Sox, he logged a 6.75 ERA, mostly on mop-up-duty, with no established track record as a reliable rotation piece.

Look—players reinvent themselves overseas all the time. Merrill Kelly, Erick Fedde, Chris Flexen and others turned KBO/NPB success into real MLB value. But they did it by pairing dominant, repeatable stuff with strong command and a track record of durability. Anderson’s KBO numbers are promising, but they don’t guarantee that kind of breakout. This is a lottery ticket, not a foundational rotation addition.

Tigers can't pretend that signing Drew Anderson solves anything in 2026

Anderson is not the type of signing that raises the ceiling of the team. He’s the type of signing you make after you already raised the ceiling.

The Tigers need impact. Period. They need a legitimate starter behind Tarik Skubal, someone who takes pressure off Reese Olson and Casey Mize, and protection in case Jackson Jobe hits any bumps in the road in his return from Tommy John surgery. They also need insurance for the bullpen so that A.J. Hinch isn’t running relievers into the ground by May.

Skubal’s situation has made the stakes painfully clear. The market is expensive, the trade market is brutal, and the Tigers have already been reminded—thanks to deals like Dylan Cease’s monster Toronto Blue Jays contract—that ace-level pitching does not come cheap. The Tigers can’t shop exclusively in the “hope and prayer” aisle if they intend to take the next step toward contending for a title.

Anderson might end up being a sneaky, useful piece. He might even exceed expectations. But if Detroit’s idea of “upgrading the pitching staff” is banking on a 31-year-old who hasn’t pitched in MLB in four years, then this offseason is off to the wrong kind of familiar start.