100 MPH are incredibly tantalizing. River Ryan is more than capable of rearing back and launching 100, hitting 101 in a May outing in Triple-A Oklahoma City. Thus far in his development, he's been viewed as a starting pitcher due to his vast six-pitch repertoire that can easily devastate a hitter when his control is reigned in. Bu career long injury troubles have led to Ryan still being a top prospect at age-28 after a dazzling but brief debut with Los Angeles in 2024.
Tigers' insiders, prominently Lynn Henning, have proposed the idea that Ryan, in order to preserve his health, might be best served in a relief role. This idea works on paper and has started to excite fans for this year in particular, but which role should the Tigers actually pursue for 2027?
The justification for closer
Plain and simple, the clearest reason for sending Ryan out to pitch the ninth is durability. Despite being a starting pitcher for his entire minor league journey, he has only accumulated 217 1/3 innings over four seasons in the minors, amounting to just over 50 per year, and heavily imbalanced by one 100-inning season in 2023. He's been fantastic over that stretch, of course, with 10.7 strikeouts per nine innings, and just 7.9 hits per nine.
But another reasoning that stands out is Ryan's occasional lapses in command. 3.5 walks per nine innings isn't a huge number, but it is fairly high for a full time starter, and lends itself to a career WHIP of 1.270, slightly above average. In a reliever setting, where stuff is maximized and walks matter slightly less due to each individual inning being treated as that player's entire game, it makes sense why anyone with doubts about his ability to sustain command would feel better with him pitching in selective opportunities.
On average, a high-level power closer has two pitches that generate 30%+ whiff rates. For his professional career, Ryan has three such offerings, his cutter, four-seam, and changeup. Four-seam fastball whiff rates tend to go down at the MLB level, but that's still two highly viable swing-and-miss options. At the very least, there is a clear recipe for "closer success potential."
Maximizing value
As much as baseball statisticians have prepared for the complete elimination of the starter pitcher in its original form, the concept has lived on far longer than predicted. Starting pitchers still regularly go 5-6 innings and have actually become even more adept at accruing strikeouts, but a slightly smaller sample. In this sense, keeping Ryan as a starter as long as his health allows is the highest value decision.
There isn't a reliable way to track whether or not Ryan maintains his stuff or results into the third time through an order yet, but when tracking his progression over his one full season, 2023, there is a clear decline over time in his performance output. In April, he posted an ERA under 2.00, but by June and July, the ERA was well into the 3.00s, before a poor September completed his line. This is indicative that he may have struggles keeping up his stuff even when health is not an overall concern.
But, there is always the possbility that this was due to a hidden injury or fatigue from a larger workload than ever before. After all, he did have Tommy John surgery the next season and didn't pitch at all in 2025.
The clearest conclusion I can reach is that him being a lockdown reliever at this point in his career would be a shrewd, reasonable decision. I'm unsure that it will happen, as Ryan was given starts in his two Tigers outings in 2026, and he was the pitcher in the Tarik Skubal trade. I also think that like Clay Holmes, Michael King, and Seth Lugo, keeping him as a starter as he matures could absolutely be the right decision.
The Tigers still have a ton of years of control, the best decision they can make is to put him in spots to be healthy and successful. Ultimately, I think based on my research, I find I agree with Henning and the others who support the idea of him being a leverage reliever in 2027.
