Adding top prospects Josue BriceƱo and Max Anderson to the major league roster were widely expected moves for the Tigers. Both were eligible for the Rule 5 draft and would've been snapped up in an instant if they weren't protected, and Scott Harris has already teased both having roles on the major league team in 2027.
But Harris also added a lesser-known prospect in shortstop Peyton Graham, who's unranked in the Tigers' pipeline (for now). He was a second-round pick for the Tigers in 2022, and he's been a slow riser through the organization. He rose from Single-A to Double-A in 2024, but was bumped back to High-A by the start of 2025.
After a decent showing there, he finally received a full-time promotion to Double-A in 2026 and hit .290 with an .826 OPS in 115 games. The truly eye-popping stat: he stole 66 bases. His .800+ OPS was largely thanks to a .397 OBP.
There's not a ton of power here, but strong defense, contact hitting, plate discipline, and speed are strong pluses. It's a pretty similar profile to that of John Peck, who didn't impress much during his brief audition at the end of 2026.
Tigers Rule 5 draft protectee Peyton Graham could create direct competition for John Peck in 2027
The Tigers seem very excited about Peck. They only needed him to play six games at Triple-A this year before they promoted him to the majors in late August. But in his 24 big league games from August 1 through the end of the season, he hit .162 with a .451 OPS and made some notable defensive gaffes at shortstop.
He also hasn't impressed much in the Arizona Fall League despite a hopeful-seeming outburst early on, hitting .169 with a .522 OPS (the fourth-lowest of any AFL batter) in 20 games.
There are no guarantees that he starts the season on the Opening Day roster, especially given how crowded the Tigers' infield already is, and if Graham gets a promotion to Triple-A to start the season, he and Peck will be evaluated side-by-side in Toledo, and Graham could end up falling further into favor with Detroit's brass.
There's no need to rush Graham (they did it with Peck and it didn't work), but now that he has a place on the 40-man roster, some of the Tigers' fringier infielders should be looking over their shoulders.
