Skip to main content

Tigers' Silver Slugger sweep still leaves questions for Detroit's offense in 2027

3-for-3!
ByKatrina Stebbins
Detroit Tigers v San Diego Padres
Detroit Tigers v San Diego Padres | Sean M. Haffey/GettyImages

The Tigers had three shots at being represented among Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger award winners (four, if you consider that Kevin McGonigle was nominated in two categories), and on Tuesday, FanSided revealed that they had pulled off a clean sweep. McGonigle and Dillon Dingler both won their first career Silver Sluggers at utility and catcher, respectively, and Riley Greene won his second in the outfield.

This isn't terribly surprising. McGonigle was generally one of the most valuable players in baseball this year, Dingler's first half was so good that it wasn't devasted by his second, and Greene is turning into a perennial All-Star.

Detroit has an incredibly solid foundation in these three players, and Max Clark should emerge as another core piece while getting more run next season. But if you look beyond him, the offense still has a lot of holes.

There's certainly potential in guys like Eduardo Valencia, Hao-Yu Lee, and maybe even Brett Callahan's bats. Spencer Torkelson and Kerry Carpenter are about as closed to grizzled veterans as this team gets, and they tend to hit anywhere between 16 and 21 homers a year on average. But it still feels like the Tigers are missing one piece to complete the puzzle.

Three Tigers Silver Slugger wins prove the offense is trending in the right direction, but it needs one last piece

Scott Harris made it clear at GM Meetings that the Tigers' focus this offseason is going to be on pitching, right before he signed Emilio Pagán to a one-year deal. Detroit has also been said to have interest in Raisel Iglesias, Shota Imanaga, and NPB free agent Kaima Taira.

There's been a lot less noise around position players. Luis Arraez and Jazz Chisholm Jr. have been vaguely named as "fits" for Detroit, but there's a distinct lack of confirmation that there's any real interest. Neither would give the Tigers exactly what they need, and the front office might not be willing to spend the money necessary to get them anyway.

They also scouted Teruaki Sato during his Triple Crown season in NPB, but that doesn't necessarily mean they'll be willing to bid high on him.

The Tigers won't be helpless next year, especially if Dingler can bounce back from his poor August and September, but Detroit's problems this season weren't purely pitching-based. The core will make adjustments and improvements, but adding a veteran bat with a good track record would offer some peace of mind that things won't turn out the same way they did in 2026.

Add us as a preferred source on Google