Skip to main content

Tigers' uneventful non-tender deadline has fans hoping trades come next

Well, okay then.
ByKatrina Stebbins
Pittsburgh Pirates v Detroit Tigers
Pittsburgh Pirates v Detroit Tigers | Duane Burleson/GettyImages

The Tigers' biggest move of non-tender day was extending Troy Melton on a six-year, $46.5 million deal. The high from that isn't likely to wear off soon, nor can it be entirely diminished by Detroit's underwhelming decisions when it came to arbitration-eligible players.

They formally non-tendered Matt Vierling, Trey Sweeney, and Jake Miller, who were DFA'ed in the Rule 5 roster crunch, but they decided to keep on their remaining 10 arbitration-eligible players. That includes candidates who once seemed obvious — Beau Brieske, Wenceel Pérez, and Zach McKinstry.

Brieske was the only real option to be non-tendered. The Tigers seem to like Pérez when he's actually be able to stay healthy, and they love McKinstry, especially after his All-Star and Silver Slugger-winning 2025 season justified their faith in him that Tigers fans haven't always been on the same page about.

However, with the roster still full at 40 and some space needed to be made for new additions, there's still the possibility of trades of any of the players who were tendered contracts. None would be major, unless Detroit was actually willing to part with Spencer Torkelson, but they could be packaged together to make a decent deal.

Tigers keep all 10 arbitration-eligible players on non-tender day after extending Troy Melton

If the Tigers were going to get rid of McKinstry, who has long drawn the ire of fans and did so again in 2026, when he failed to replicate the success of his 2025 season, they wouldn't have tendered him a contract. Despite how much fans might want him gone, the Tigers have always been firm in their belief that he's a critical part of any of their rosters. They love him for his defensive versatility, and he has his moments at the plate.

On the other hand, Pérez and Meadows could be moved. Tigers fans have been vastly overestimating their worth in a trade, but a small-time deal for prospects who aren't on the buying team's 40-man rosters could be more plausible.

The Tigers did what they needed to do with Jace Jung, Sweeney, and Vierling, but it seems like that was enough daringness for them. It's unsurprising that they mostly stuck to their guns when it came to tendering contracts.

Still, it's not a complete assurance of any of these players' safety, and if Scott Harris actually intends to make good on his vow to keep making the roster better by acquiring major league arms, he's going to have to trim some players regardless.

Add us as a preferred source on Google