Skip to main content

White Sox's costly Dustin May deal just put Tigers' chances at Shota Imanaga in jeopardy

HOW much?
ByKatrina Stebbins
World Series: Milwaukee Brewers v Tampa Bay Rays - Game Four
World Series: Milwaukee Brewers v Tampa Bay Rays - Game Four | Carmen Mandato/GettyImages

Baseball fans have been waiting for a torrent of activity on the free agent market since GM Meetings, but it was mostly kept to a slow trickle during and in the immediate aftermath.

The Tigers were the first to make a move, signing reliever Emilio Pagán to a one-year, $11.5 million deal. A few more relievers have come off the board since then, but we haven't exactly seen the mad rush to sign that insiders were expecting.

World Series champion Jake Bauers signed with the Red Sox for four years and $58 million on Friday, and it signaled a larger floodgate opening. Another former Brewer came off the board on Tuesday, when the White Sox signed another World Series champion in Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract.

That not only signals that the market is about to really start moving, but that it's about to go haywire.

May never pitched more than 56 innings in a single season through the first five years of his career as a starter. He missed 2024 entirely with a number of health issues, and he's posted a 4.82 ERA for four years in the two seasons since. And the White Sox are going to pay him $17.5 million a year.

If that's going to be the going rate for starters, the Tigers may balk at Shota Imanaga's price tag.

Tigers division rival White Sox sign Dustin May to a ridiculous three-year, $52.5 million contract

Evan Petzold and Jon Morosi have both turned up the heat on Tigers-Imanaga rumors in recent days, and he makes sense to round out Detroit's rotation.

He had his struggles in 2025 and 2026, but he mostly stayed healthy and posted a solid 3.45 ERA across his three years as a Cub. He initially signed a deal worth $13.25 million a year and accepted a $22.025 million qualifying offer last season, but a contract worth $18 million per year with escalators didn't feel totally unachievable. Until now.

If May is making $17.5 million a year, Imanaga could plausibly ask for something closer to the low- or mid-$20-millions per year, and the Tigers may not be willing to go that high.

If Imanaga ends up going elsewhere for to a team that's willing to give him a two-year, $50 million contract or something in that realm, Tigers fans will be able to blame the White Sox for it. But at least May's history of injury and poor performance doesn't exactly bode well for his tenure in Chicago. That's what you get for being bamboozled by a World Series trophy, we suppose.

Add us as a preferred source on Google