Detroit Tigers Draft Picks: Top First-Round Picks Since 2000

5. Andrew Miller, SP 2006

Taken just a few years after Justin Verlander, Miller was thought to be the next great frontline starting pitcher for the Detroit Tigers.

However, things didn’t get off to the best start for the starter. Due to a deep rotation, Miller was limited to eight relief outings as a rookie in 2006. The left-hander was tagged for 10 walks, nine runs and eight hits in 10.1 innings pitched. He only struck out six batters. Overall, his FIP ended up at an uninspiring 5.47.

A move back to the rotation in 2007 didn’t help Miller either. The former first-round pick went 5-5 with a 5.63 ERA (5.27 FIP) in 13 starts, totaling 64 innings pitched. Those would be the last appearances made by the lefty in Detroit.

Miller was shipped to the Marlins along with another player on this list, Cameron Maybin, for Miguel Cabrera. Also involved in the trade were Dallas Trahern, Mike Rabelo, Frankie De La Cruz and Burke Badenhop. Dontrelle Willis came to Motown with Cabrera.

After leaving Detroit, Andrew Miller would continue to struggle as a starter. Opposing batters hit .296 off the lefty. This led to an unsightly 5.70 career ERA when starting ballgames.

A transition to the bullpen has done wonders for the talented former Tiger. Since making the switch to relief full time in 2012, the lefty has developed into one of the game’s premier relievers. He’s closed 43 games while posting a 2.19 FIP and 330 strikeouts in only 210.2 innings pitched split between the Red Sox, Orioles and Yankees.

4. Cameron Maybin, CF 2005

With a miniscule 1.71 FIP since the start of 2014, one could make the argument that Miller has been more of an impact player as of late, but Maybin has been much more consistent over the course of his career.  What’s more, the outfielder’s 9.6 lifetime WAR is more than three times higher than the pitcher’s 3.0 WAR.

Since leaving Detroit, Maybin has played for three different teams, the Marlins, Padres and Braves. In three years with Florida, the 29-year-old hit .257 with 43 RBI, 21 doubles, 14 stolen baes, 12 home runs and five triples

However, he was never able to play more than 82 games in a season, and was dealt to San Diego before 2011. Maybin showed off his potential in 2011 and 2012 with the Padres, posting a .253 batting average and averaging 42 RBI, 22 doubles, 33 stolen bases, eight home runs and six triples per seasons.

He continued to show promise with Atlanta last season, stuffing the stat sheet with 59 RBI, 23 stolen bases, 18 doubles, 10 home runs and a pair of triples.

Al Avila acquired him in what could turn out to be a steal. The relatively new Tigers general manager flipped Ian Krol—he of a 5.18 FIP in 60.2 innings for Detroit—and Single-A pitcher Gabe Speier to Atlanta for Maybin.

The center fielder has been slowed by injuries in the early going, but made his debut on Monday. During that game, the 29-year-old went 2-for-2 with a walk, a run and a stolen base. He also provided capable defense in the cavernous Comerica Park.

Maybin will add a much-needed base running threat to the Tigers lineup, not to mention a steady defensive presence in center field.

3. Nick Castellanos, 3B 2010

When the Detroit Tigers drafted Nick Castellanos with the 44^th-overall pick in the 2010 draft, there was never any doubt that the third baseman could hit.

Castellanos immediately made good on his promise, hitting .303 in 410 career minor league games.

After a brief cup of coffee in 2013 that saw him hit .278 in 18 plate appearances, the 24-year-old logged his first full season at the Major League debut in 2014.

During that campaign, Castellanos finished managed a .259 batting average to go along with 66 RBI, 31 doubles, 11 home runs and four triples. The 2015 season saw the Florida native makes strides as he upped his total numbers of doubles (33), triples (six), home runs (15) and RBI (73). His batting average dropped to .255, but the former outfielder did up his OPS from .700 to .721.

So far this season, Nick Castellanos is making good on his exciting potential. The third baseman currently leads the American League with a stellar .348 batting average. His .984 OPS isn’t too shabby either.

In just 36 games, Castellanos has 30 RBI, which is nine more than any other hitter in the Detroit batting order.

2. Rick Porcello, SP 2007

If Castellanos can continue to produce at a level similar to his current form, he’ll easily climb to number two on this list. However, for now, that spot belongs to Rick Porcello.

While he no longer suits up for Detroit, Porcello was a solid contributor for the Tigers for six years.

The right-handed starter spent only one season in the minors before making the leap to the Majors. He immediately made an impact with 14 wins, a 3.96 ERA and a 2.5 WAR.

It was a struggle at times for Porcello, who’s ERA was almost always above 4.00. From 2010 to 2013, the starter’s ERAs were 4.92, 4.75, 4.59 and 4.32.

Despite the relatively high ERA numbers, Porcello always came through with double-digit wins. The 2015 season in Boston marked the first time the former Tiger failed to notch at least 10 victories. Still, the 27-year-old already has 91 wins to his name.

Even though he pitches for the Red Sox, the Tigers are still reaping the benefits of the deal that sent Porcello to Boston.

Detroit acquired reliever Alex Wilson, prospect Gabe Speier and outfielder Yoenis Cespedes in the transaction.

Wilson has become an effective reliever for the Tigers, posting a 2.86 ERA in 82.2 innings pitched for Brad Ausmus’ team. Speier, as noted earlier, was flipped to Atlanta with Ian Krol for Maybin.

Lastly, there’s Cespedes, who produced at a high level for half a season before being shipped to the Mets for Michael Fulmer—perhaps the team’s ace of the future— and fellow pitcher Luis Cessa. Cessa and pitching prospect Chad Green were dealt to the Yankees this past offseason for another effective reliever with Wilson as a surname, Justin Wilson.

1.  Justin Verlander, SP 2004

Perhaps it is fitting that the Tigers’ highest draft pick this century has also been the best.

Justin Verlander has been everything a team would want out of a top draft pick.

Only 33-years-old and already with a Hall of Fame-worthy resume, Verlander has been excellent in a Detroit uniform.

During his first full season in the big leagues, the right-hander won 17 games while pitching to a 3.63 ERA. He helped Detroit to the franchise’s first World Series appearance since 1984.

The man referred to by many as “JV” has, among other things, led the Tigers to another World Series appearance since 2006.

In addition to leading Detroit to American League titles in both 2006 and 2012, Verlander became the first pitcher since 1992 to win an MVP award when he went 24-5 with a 2.40 ERA and 250 strikeouts in 251 innings pitched.

That season, the righty led the league in wins, ERA, games started, innings pitched, strikeouts, WHIP and hits per nine innings.

Verlander also won the Cy Young award and also became the second American League pitcher this century to win the pitching Triple Crown.

The ace’s resume also includes six All-Star game appearances, two no-hitters and the 2006 Rookie of the Year trophy. To top it all off, Verlander became a lights-out starter in the playoffs. He held the A’s and Yankees to three combined runs en route to the 2012 World Series, while also limiting the A’s and Red Sox to just one run in 23 innings in 2013.

Next: 3 Players That Can Improve the Bench

The longtime Detroit Tigers pitcher is only 2-4 with a 4.71 ERA this season, but he’s been dominant in his last two starts, posting a 0.60 ERA and 17 strikeouts in 15 innings pitched.