Detroit Tigers Represented on 2018 Hall of Fame Ballot

Johnny Damon

Johnny Damon had a very accomplished 18-year career. He knocked out 2,769 hits and scored 1,668 runs.

Damon spent his first six seasons in Kansas City before playing in Oakland for one year and spending the next four years with the Red Sox.

Boston is where he will be most remembered. He was a key component of the famous 2004 team that came back from a 3-0 deficit to defeat the Yankees. They went on to sweep the Cardinals in the 2004 World Series and broke an 86 year drought for Boston.

Damon then spent four years on the Yankees before coming to Detroit for the 2010 season.

Damon was primarily the Tigers designated hitter in 2010.

He played in 145 games, slashing .271/.355/.410. He hit 36 doubles and eight home runs, stole 11 bases and posted a .756 OPS.

Damon finished out his career with one year each in Tampa Bay and Cleveland before retiring in 2012.

Damon had a very solid career, but not one that will end with him reaching the Hall of Fame.

According to Baseball Reference, His bWAR of 56 and JAWS score of 44.4 both fall short of the average HOF center fielder (71.2 and 57.9, respectively).

He racked up a lot of hits and a lot of runs scored, but his poor defense, average power and average speed might keep him out of the Hall of Fame.

Aubrey Huff

Every year, players are chosen for the Hall of Fame ballot simply because they played ten or more seasons in Major League Baseball. These players rarely get a vote for the Hall of Fame, but they get their name briefly back in the spotlight as their career is acknowledged.

Aubrey Huff is one of those players.

According to Baseball Reference, in his 13-year career Huff won one Silver Slugger Award and finished top-10 in MVP voting once.

He was never an All-Star, never led the league in any offensive category and falls considerably short of what a traditional Hall of Fame first baseman’s career looks like.

Huff broke into the bigs with Tampa Bay in 2000 and spent seven years with them before a brief stint in Houston with the Astros. From there he spent a few years with the Orioles before being traded in August of 2009 to the Tigers for minor leaguer Brett Jacobson.

Huff hit .189 with two home runs in 106 at-bats with the Tigers before signing with the San Francisco Giants, where he retired in 2012 after winning his second World Series ring.

Huff finished with 242 home runs and a 20.2 bWAR and might not come anywhere close to reaching the 5% threshold necessary to remain on the ballot.

Gary Sheffield

Gary Sheffield is entering his fourth year on the ballot, having earned 13.3% of the vote last year. He earned 11.7% in 2015 and 11.6% in 2016.

The likelihood of his support increasing from 13% to 75% over the next six years are slim. Sheffield might have to wait for the Veteran’s Committee to give him a chance at induction.

Sheffield played for eight different teams across 22 seasons, blasting 509 home runs and slashing .292/.393/.514 in his illustrious career.

The outfielder and designed hitter joined the Tigers in November of 2006 in a trade with the New York Yankees. The Tigers surrendered three prospects in the deal; Anthony Claggett, Humberto Sanchez and Kevin Whelan.

Sheffield spent two years in the Motor City, hitting .247 with 44 home runs, 31 stolen bases and a .788 OPS.

He was released after the 2008 season and signed with the New York Mets to close out his career.

Sheffield’s lack of support from voters could stem from an overcrowded ballot. Voters are only allowed to vote for 10 players. With a plethora of talent on the ballot, some players might not get as many votes.

Sheffield was one of the greatest power hitters of his generation, but has a long road ahead of him before he sees his name on a plaque in Cooperstown.

Omar Vizquel

While not technically a Tiger, Omar Vizquel was hired in November of 2013 to be the Detroit Tigers first base coach.

Under former manager Brad Ausmus, Vizquel also served as the Tigers infield and base-running coach.

He resided in that role through last season, but won’t return as part of the new Detroit coaching staff.

Vizquel is certainly qualified to coach infield and baserunning, two areas he excelled at in his 24-year career.

Vizquel opened up his career in Seattle, playing five seasons there and winning one Gold Glove.

He then spent 11 season as a member of the Cleveland Indians, winning eight Gold Glove Awards and making three All-Star games.

Vizquel won two more Gold Glove Awards in his four years with the Giants before bouncing around the Rangers, White Sox and Blue Jays to finish out his career.

Vizquel’s 11 Gold Glove Awards are tied for sixth all-time among position players, second only to Ozzie Smith among shortstops. His 28.4 dWAR is 10th all time.

There is no doubt that Vizquel is one of the greatest defensive players in the history of baseball, but is he Hall worthy?

His 82 OPS+ is substantially below average. His 2,877 hits is nice but his 80 home runs and 404 stolen bases are both not up to par for Hall of Famers, even at shortstop.

Next: Ian Kinsler replacements if the second baseman is traded

Vizquel will get plenty of votes for the HOF, but a crowded ballot may keep him short of induction in his first season. However, there is a good chance he will eventually wind up in Cooperstown.