Detroit Tigers: Alan Trammell's Journey to the Hall of Fame

1 of 3

OAKLAND, CA – JUNE 25: Alan Trammell #3 of the Detroit Tigers fields the ball during the game against the Oakland Athletics at Oakland-Alameda Coliseum on June 25, 1996 in Oakland, California. The Tigers defeated the A’s 10-8. (Photo by Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images) /

Detroit Tigers fans have a reason to go to Cooperstown this summer, with two legends in Alan Trammell and Jack Morris getting inducted into the Hall of Fame.

For 17 years, a vicious battle raged between the BBWAA and Detroit Tigers fans over whether Jack Morris was a Hall of Famer. At least there was an argument.

For Alan Trammell, and his possible candidacy into the Hall, hardly a voice was raised!

Trammell became eligible for Hall of Fame consideration in 2002. It was the two years earlier that venerable Tiger manager Sparky Anderson became a member of that lofty institution.

Unlike Anderson, Hall of Fame voters did not look favorably on Trammell. To be elected into the Hall, a candidate’s name must appear on 75% of the writer’s ballots.

In 2002 balloting, Trammell garnered only 22%.

The New Breed of shortstops

Trammell was part of the evolution of the “new breed” of shortstops. No longer was the major league shortstop all glove and ‘no-bat’.

The slick fielding shortstop of old, who typically batted eighth in the order, gave way to great hitting and great fielding.

That definition of the ” new breed” of major league shortstops arose out of the introduction of Robin Yount, Cal Ripken and Trammell into the MLB.

Yount and Ripken could not only hit for average and provide solid defense but also could, and did, hit for power. This new breed of shortstop was never seen before in the big leagues.

The major league shortstop, beginning in the mid 1970’s, could hit for power, hit for average, had good arm strength and fielding abilities.

The young Trammell would find himself in this group of shortstops. He would add good base running skills into the mix. Trammell would also find himself #3 in this “group of three”.

Yount was a 20 year veteran of the Major leagues. He would play his entire career for the Milwaukee Brewers (1973 – 1992). Yount would play primarily as a shortstop and, later in his career, as a centerfielder. As a Brewer, Yount would post astronomical statistics.

The two-time American league MVP and 3-time All-star would have a career .285 BA, 3,142 hits, 251 Home Runs, 1406 RBI’s and won a Golden Glove in 1982.

Cal Ripken Jr. was known as the “Iron Man” for having played in 2,632 consecutive games for the Baltimore Orioles (1981 – 2001). His accolades arising from this feat are breathtaking.

The Iron man amassed 19 All-Star appearances, 2x MVPs, Rookie of the Year honors in 1982, two Golden Glove Awards, eight Silver Slugger Awards and led his team to a World Championship in 1983. Ripken did all this while he was compiling 3,184 hits, 431 Home runs, 1695 RBI’s and had a career .276 batting average.

Both Yount and Ripken would ultimately be first ballot Hall of Famers. Ripken’s name showed up on 98.53% of the ballots, the fourth highest of all time.

It was out of this same period of time that Trammell would play and, ultimately, find his name on Hall of Fame ballots.

CHICAGO – 1990: Alan Trammell #3 of the Detroit Tigers bats during a game in the 1990 season against the Chicago White Sox at Comiskey Park in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

Trammell’s Hall of Fame Balloting

With new tools used for assessing potential Hall of Fame candidates, the BBWAA seemed to discard the sabermetric tools when judging Trammell.

These same tools were the basis for the argument that Jack Morris should not be considered a Hall of Fame Candidate.

The writers did not compare Trammell against all-time shortstops but against Yount and Ripken. Had the Detroit Tiger been compared to Hall of Fame shortstops of the past, he might have been a first ballot selection.

In the eyes of the writers, Trammell fell short. During the 15 years on the BBWAA ballots, Tram received on average 15% to 20% of the votes. He did not exceed 40% until his last year on the ballot.

Modern Baseball Era Committee

Previously known as the Veterans committee, The Eras committee is composed of six Hall of Fame players, a Hall of Fame manager, and an assortment of executives, BBWAA members and a historian.

In December 2017, the Era’s committee righted grievous wrongs. With the likes of George Brett, Rod Carew and Robin Yount all voting, the committee voted Alan Trammell and Jack Morris into the Hall of Fame.

The 16 member committee felt that the two were worthy of selection. Certainly, that group of Hall of Fame members knew who were the dominate and great player contemporaries of that period.

DETROIT – APRIL 20: Manager Alan Trammell #3 of the Detroit Tigers greets former player Jack Morris as both took part in a ceremony to launch the Ameriquest offical balloting for the All Star voting before the game between the Chicago White Sox and the Detroit Tigers at Comerica Park on April 20, 2005 in Detroit, Michigan. The White Sox defeated the Tigers 9-1. (Photo by Tom Pidgeon/Getty Images) /

The Early Years

Just a few miles from downtown San Diego sits the neighborhood hamlet of Kearny Mesa. It was here at Kearny High School and while playing American Legion ball that Trammell honed his baseball skills.

The Detroit Tigers drafted Trammell in 1976 and he signed with the team, forgoing his dream of playing baseball at UCLA.

In perhaps the greatest draft in team history, the Tigers selected Trammell in the second round in 1976. The Tigers also selected Dan Petry in the fourth round, Morris in the fifth round and Ozzie Smith in the seventh round, who did not sign.

After less than a year and a half, Trammell was brought up to the big league club and was paired with second baseman Lou Whitaker.

The two would end up playing together until 1995. The double play combination would play together for a MLB record of 1,918 games.

His Playing Years

While Trammell would not collect 3000 hits, as did Yount and Ripken, he would be an offensive force. In his 20 year career, Trammell would amass a batting average of .285, 2,365 hits, 185 home runs and 1,003 RBI.

Trammell was a 6x All-Star (1980, 84, 85, 87, 88 and 1990). He was also a 4x Gold Glove winner (1980, 81, 83 and 1984) and won the Silver Slugger Award in 1987,1988 and 1990.

He won the World Series MVP during his team’s championship run in 1984.

His defensive skills consisted of great fielding range, a terrific glove, a quick release and accurate throwing ability.

In addition, the Tiger Great also had 236 career stolen bases.

For the sabermetric clan, Trammell’s stats placed him 11th all-time among shortstops.

Next: Jack Morris, the Hall of Famer

In spite of the BBWAA membership tripping over themselves as to who qualifies as a Hall of Famer, contemporary players and fans knew Alan Trammell was a Hall of Famer.

The Era’s committee finally resolved the issue. Those that played the game established what fans had known all along, Alan Trammell was indeed a Hall of Famer.

Alan Trammell will be inducted into Cooperstown in July of 2018. Hopefully his longtime double-play partner Lou Whitaker will be there to witness an award that in-turn will be awarded to him.

Home / Detroit Tigers History

Detroit Tigers: From Kearney Mesa to Cooperstown, Alan Trammell’s Journey to the Hall

Detroit Tigers fans have a reason to go to Cooperstown this summer, with two legends in Alan Trammell and Jack Morris getting inducted into the Hall of Fame.

Schedule