Detroit Tigers: Minor-league pitcher top 10s
The 2021 minor-league season is over, so we thought now would be a good time to take a look back at some of the best statistical performances from pitchers in the Detroit Tigers system.
Last week we checked in on the top 10 offensive performances in various categories. We’ve had to get a bit creative with the pitching lists, because if we stuck to just qualified pitchers, we’d be picking from only 12 starters.
To combat that, we’ve lowered the innings limit to just 30. That gives us 76 qualified names, and though it may skew a few stats, we’ll do our best to explain any wacky numbers.
So, let’s begin with some traditional stats. Pitcher wins might be the least informative traditional stat in baseball, but certain people still care about them, so here we go.
Detroit Tigers Minor League Wins Leaders
What you’ll notice here is a lot of minor-league free agents who aren’t really prospects. That doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be celebrated, because finding arms to eat innings this year was a daunting task for every team in baseball. Ricardo Pinto ended up leading all of minor-league baseball with 14 wins. Mark Leiter Jr., Pedro Payano, and Drew Hutchison were all vital to Toledo’s success this year, and Hutchison added three more victories at the MLB level.
Beau Brieske is the first real prospect on the list, and his performance was strong enough to earn him Detroit Tigers Minor League Pitcher of the Year honors from the team. And then Reese Olson sneaks onto the list, having won five games in the Milwaukee system before coming to Detroit in the Daniel Norris trade.
We don’t want to leave the relievers out this discussion, so now let’s take a look at this year’s saves leaders.
Detroit Tigers Minor League Saves Leaders
As a stat, saves aren’t a whole lot more useful than wins, particularly in the minors. Most relievers at the lower levels aren’t allowed to pitch on back-to-back nights, and often the closing opportunities go to any pitcher who didn’t make the rotation. There are the occasional reliever prospects, like Zack Hess, who the Tigers drafted in the 7th round in 2019, but most minor-league closers are veterans like Cale Coshow and Gerson Moreno.
Wins and saves tend to come from a mix of execution, luck, and opportunity. So who had the most opportunity this year? Let’s take a look at the leaders in games and innings pitched.
Detroit Tigers Minor League Games Pitched Leaders
Detroit Tigers Minor League Innings Pitched Leaders
There’s not a whole heck of a lot to do with these lists. Jarey Tobey is a lefty from Wayne State who has a good arm, but pitched to a 5.36 ERA this year. Adam Wolf is another southpaw from the 2018 draft who was a little bit like the low-minors version of Tyler Alexander this year, using a mix of sinkers, sliders/cutters, and changeups to keep hitters off balance.
Detroit Tigers: Minor-league Pitching top 10s
Fair or not, modern pitchers tend to be judged on their ability to miss bats. Strikeouts aren’t the only means to success, of course, but they do seem to make things easier on pitchers. So let’s look at Detroit’s leaders in a few strikeout categories.
Detroit Tigers Minor League Pitching Strikeout Leaders
Mark Leiter Jr. struck out 106 batters in his 114 career big-league innings, so it shouldn’t be too much of a surprise he racked up the Ks in the minors this year. Still, he deserves credit for helping Toledo win their division. He was dominant down the stretch, and his September 10th outing against Iowa (7IP, 4H, 0ER, 0BB, 14K) was one of the better performances in the minors this year.
We also get the first appearance of Austin Bergner, Detroit’s 9th-round pick in 2019. He began the year in the bullpen in Low-A Lakeland, but by the end of the season he was a key part of West Michigan’s rotation. Brendan White also made a successful transition from the bullpen to the rotation, while Arizona Fall League invitee Garrett Hill quietly put together a dominant season.
Detroit Tigers Minor League Pitching K/9 Leaders
As we might expect, the list of the best strikeout-per-nine pitchers in the Detroit Tigers system is heavy with relievers. For those wondering, Gabriel Sequeira and Chris Mauloni both throw a lot of low-90s sinkers. Isrrael De La Cruz is a former infielder who can touch the mid-90s and has a decent curve.
The lone starting pitcher on this list is Wilmer Flores, who is one of the more fascinating pitchers in the system. An undrafted free agent in 2020, Flores quickly moved from the Florida Complex League to Low-A this year, and after a bumpy introduction he became one of the most dominant pitchers in the league. He allowed just one run on eight hits and six walks over his final three starts of the season, striking out 22 in 16.2 innings. The Tigers sent him to the AFL, where he’s one of the youngest players in the league ($).
Wins, saves, and strikeouts are all fun, but pitching is ultimately about preventing runs. So let’s finish with a couple of stats to see who did the best job keeping their opponents off the board.
Detroit Tigers Minor League ERA Leaders
We have an interesting mix of starters and relievers here, and a couple of names that haven’t shown up on previous lists. Australian lefty Jack O’Loughlin has a fringy fastball and some interesting secondary offerings, but his strikeout rate plummeted from 26.5% to 10.3% when he moved up to High-A.
Rayner Castillo was one of Detroit’s big signings in the 2020 international class, and he definitely lived up to expectations in his first taste of pro ball. Castillo just turned 17 at the end of June, so he’s likely to be one of the youngest players in his league in 2022, whether he sticks in the Florida Complex League or gets an aggressive assignment to Low-A.
Detroit Tigers Minor League FIP Leaders
We’ll finish with Detroit’s FIP leaders. For those unfamiliar, FIP is an ERA estimator designed to tell us how a pitcher should have performed if we remove defense, luck, and timing from the equation. This can be particularly useful for minor-league pitchers, as lower-quality defense can have an outsized impact on a pitcher’s ERA.
The Detroit Tigers don’t have a farm system flush with pitching right now, which is probably why they made arms such a priority in the draft this year. But Beau Brieske, Rayner Castillo, Wilmer Flores, Garrett Hill, and Reese Olson all deserve some attention in 2022 and beyond, and it wouldn’t be a shock to see at least one of them develop into a quality MLB pitcher.