Detroit Tigers: 3 prospects who will not make their debut in Detroit
Detroit Tigers are going to undergo some serious reconstruction.
The Detroit Tigers are going to be shaking things up. Their roster will look much different by the time the 2023 season rolls around, and I’d expect that wholesale change to continue beyond the 2023 season. The new president of baseball operations, Scott Harris, has made it clear that things will change.
Between shaking things up with the big league roster, I’d expect these roster moves to be from all levels of the organization. Trades to part ways with prospects that Harris was not high on. There’s likely going to be a lot of them.
After all, when asked how he feels about the Tigers farm system during his introductory press conference, he replied that sharing “the Giants’ opinion” of the Tigers farm system was not fair since he was not familiar with the organization yet. In other words, Harris is not a fan.
With that being said, I’d expect Harris to be shopping prospects to teams who may be looking to bolster their farm system. This may not be the worst thing in the world, but it would do a couple of things.
Depending on the outcome of the trade, it could bring in some new talent to the farm system, swapping players who may need a new home or a fresh start for another organization’s prospects who Harris was high on.
It also could allow Harris the freedom to try and upgrade some of the positions around the field by packaging in prospects that Harris was not thrilled about. Let’s take a look at three of the Detroit Tigers prospects who could be on the chopping block.
These are three players who might find themselves making their big league debuts with another team, not making it to the bigs with the Detroit Tigers organization.
#1: Detroit Tigers starting pitching prospect, Dylan Smith
The Detroit Tigers selected Dylan Smith with the team’s third-round pick in the 2021 MLB Draft. The right-handed pitcher was expected to be able to continue defining his pitch mix and cruise through the organization’s ranks.
After a breakout 2021 season with the University of Alabama Crimson Tide, Smith was aiming to make the jump into the Tigers organization smoothly.
He did not make any appearances with the team in 2021 but came out and spent 2022 with the High-A West Michigan Whitecaps, except for two starts with Lakeland. Smith pitched 83.1 innings in total over 20 games, where he managed an 8-6 record, a 4.00 ERA, a 1.19 WHIP, and punched out 86 opposing hitters.
While Smith has shown he has the stuff to be a big leaguer, he’s got to develop this further and keep climbing up the organization’s ranks. For this reason, it feels like Smith could be packaged into a trade or dealt by Harris to try and help find some new faces for the farm system.
Smith’s got some desirable stuff when it’s on. He has a mid-90s fastball (mostly 93-95 mph) and two good breaking balls, with a splitter in the mix as his fourth offering. The slider is better than the curveball, but he’s not afraid to turn to either one.
But, things have not gone as well as the Tigers likely hoped. They may be shopping the right-handed prospect.
#2: Detroit Tigers catching prospect Dillon Dingler
The next prospect on this list was hard for me to come to grips with, but I have a hunch that Dillon Dingler might be on the trade block. It sucks, as I was really high on Dillon Dingler and his tools, but part of me feels like the Detroit Tigers might move on from him.
It’s not a move I would love, but it’s understandable. The Tigers’ backstops have been questionable, with Tucker Barnhart failing to live up to expectations and Eric Haase not being a true option for an everyday starter.
The Tigers still have yet to find their everyday backstop, and the hope was that Dingler would be that guy. The second-round pick from the 2020 draft came from Ohio State and has been working his way through the organization.
He was the insurance policy if Jake Rogers never panned out, and he has been away from the field recovering from Tommy John Surgery. But Dingler has taken his time getting through the Tigers farm system.
He spent the 2022 season with the Double-A Erie Seawolves, besides a four-game stint with the Lakeland Flying Tigers. Dingler hit .238/.333/.419 with 22 doubles, three triples, and 14 home runs in Double-A during the 2022 season. Dingler also threw out 37% of runners attempting to swipe a bag against him this summer.
The Tigers do not currently have another answer for the catching position. Josh Crouch had quite the summer after being drafted, but the former 11th-rounder does not have the pedigree to be a future all-star but is an intriguing name to follow.
Dingler’s days may be numbered with the Tigers if Harris is opting to outsource the catcher’s position and bring in someone from the outside. It sucks to say, but all of the team’s prospects are likely on the table as Harris begins to construct the team he wants and the farm system he views as valuable for the future.
#3: Detroit Tigers’ first-rounder from 2022, Jace Jung
The last prospect may surprise some, but the Detroit Tigers may not see the end of the road for Jace Jung. He may not make his big league debut with the Detroit Tigers as the team moves forward.
I’m not as high on Jace Jung as some seem to be. I think Jung will be a good player, and the bat will be exciting, but I thought there were better options available on the board. Now that’s no fault to Scott Harris, which is exactly why I could see Jung being used as a trade chip.
For Jung to pan out with the Tigers, he has to hit. He’s also got to lock down a position. They tried third base in college, which did not work out well. He’s been a second baseman since then, but he’s not the greatest defender overall.
While some folks are okay with sacrificing defense for some offense, it just goes back to the idea that I felt there were better options on the table for the Tigers that I would have liked to have seen them take instead. But that’s the Al Avila era; it’s Harris’s time now.
Harris may be open to trading Jung and seeing if he can upgrade the farm system or upgrade a position. Jung got his first taste of affiliate ball this summer with the West Michigan Whitecaps, where he logged 108 at-bats, slashing .232/.373/.333 with 28 punchouts.
Who knows, Jung could wind up being the Tigers’ future second baseman who hits for power and brings another power lefty bat to the lineup. But I’d expect there to be some trade talk with Jung’s name being waved around from Harris.
For that reason and that assumption, I added him as the third player who may not see the big leagues on this list. All three players mentioned have value; the question is if they can make it through Harris’s wholesale changes as he starts to leave his mark on the Tigers organization.