Detroit Tigers: 3 players playing their way off the roster in spring training

Detroit Tigers v Kansas City Royals
Detroit Tigers v Kansas City Royals / Kyle Rivas/GettyImages
2 of 3
Next

These players are not having good springs for the Detroit Tigers

The Detroit Tigers are trying to figure who they will take north when they head to Tropicana Field on March 30 to take on the Rays. Some players are making it very easy on the decision-makers with their poor play.

The Tigers have a lot of people vying for a spot on the Opening Day roster, and some players that we originally thought would be locks have gotten off to rough starts. There have been pitchers and hitters that fall into this category.

Here are a few Detroit Tigers that are playing themselves off the roster in spring training.

SP Matt Manning

It's been a pretty awful spring for Manning. His command has been spotty as best, his velocity has been down, and he's been giving up tons of hard contact. He's pretty much been the only starting pitcher that's had a bad spring. Matthew Boyd, Eduardo Rodriguez, and Spencer Turnbull have all been great.

Because of this, and the fact that Manning has minor league options remaining, it sure seems like the 25-year-old is headed to Toledo to begin the 2023 season. I even had him off my second Opening Day roster projection, and that was before his latest outing, where he gave up four runs in two innings.

This was the year where we really needed to something from the former first-round pick. He's dealt with injuries and inconsitency each of the last two years. This was supposed to be the year he finally shows us what he's capable of. Instead, it's looking like yet another setback.

I'm thinking Joey Wentz takes his spot in the rotation. He hasn't had a wonderful spring by any stretch of the imagination, but he at least knows where his pitches are going. Sadly, I cannot say the same for Manning. Hopefully he can get his stuff together.

INF Ryan Kreidler

Let me first say that I've never been that bullish on Kreidler. Even when he was hitting well in the minors in 2021, I took one look at this strikeout numbers and thought he wouldn't ever be more than a AAAA player. Early returns during a cup of coffee in the big leagues in 2022 suggest I was correct. But that was a very small sample, to be fair. It's also possible he was still battling a hand injury he suffered early last season. But so far in spring training, it's been more of the same.

Kreidler is really slick in the field. He's really smooth at shortstop, which does give him an advantage. None of his competiton for a roster spot has that ability, maybe with the exception of Zack Short. But he still just not a good hitter.

On the surface, his spring training numbers are solid. He's got an .829 OPS and .519 slugging percentage. But if you've watched any of his ABs, he's been pretty lucky. He's got a couple bloop doubles and some dribblers that have gotten through the infield. A lot of weak contact.

Again, I'm a bit biased because I've never been a believer in him, but I just don't see how he can make the roster when Zack Short and Andre Lipcius have been hitting as well as they have. Maybe I end up being wrong, which I certainly wouldn't be upset about, but I needless to say, I have my doubts.

LHP Tyler Alexander

Once thought to be a lock for the bullpen, Tyler Alexander has suddenly become in danger of being DFA'd. He has not looked good this spring. He has a modest 4.05 ERA as of this writing, but he's given up six hits and three runs while only striking out three in 6.2 IP. His velocity has also been down, hanging around 88-89 when he's usually 91-92.

The Tigers have several lefty options that have pitched better than Alexander, and could probably be better in his role. Tyler Holton, Chasen Shreve, and even Joey Wentz could be better in the role with better stuff than Alexander. I'm kind of shocked he's still here to begin with.

Even if he does make the team, I have a sneaking feeling he won't be here for long. If he's throwing 88 mph with no life like he has been this spring, then he's probably not long for this roster.

Next. Detroit Tigers: Spencer Turnbull looks like he hasn't missed a beat. dark

Next