Scott Harris wanting to have his cake and eat it with Tigers top prospects can't last forever

Scott Harris has done his best trying to get Tigers fans excited about a new wave of prospects in 2027. While it is exciting to a certain extent, the fact that it'll most likely be in lieu of free agent spending puts a damper on things.

However, if we buy into Harris' propagandizing for a second, there is a lot of talent to get excited about. Josue Briceño and Max Anderson are both expected to be pieces of the 2027 puzzle, and Zyhir Hope could debut later in the season. First-round pick Cameron Flukey could also be a fast riser.

But the question arises: where are the Tigers going to fit all of these players?

Briceño and Anderson both have competition at every position they play (Briceño at catcher and first, Anderson at second and third). The outfield will be incredibly bloated if all of Parker Meadows, Wenceel Pérez, and Kerry Carpenter are ready by Opening Day.

Harris has never traded a top-15 Tigers prospect. He's already alluded to Spencer Torkelson, perhaps Detroit's best hypothetical trade candidate, being a huge part of the team next season. Jace Jung, though not a Harris draft pick, has been languishing in the minors.

Harris refuses to acquire talent if it means replacing a younger and more cost-effective player. While we're currently seeing how homegrown talent can make a winning baseball team — just look at the Brewers — Harris won't take the logical next step and trade from his depth.

Scott Harris won't be able to keep all of his Tigers prospects forever

The feeling this conveys is that Harris is indecisive. Sure, he might want to give all of his top prospects a little runway in the majors before picking and choosing who makes the cut in the long-term. When players are that young and that controllable, there's not much harm in that. A large contingent of the Tigers' current major leaguers still have options, too.

But it also means running the risk of watching players just like Jung and Trey Sweeney turn into busts in real time, and their windows to be traded at a high price close. Torkelson, even for all of his struggles, could fetch a decent price in a trade, but his value will continue to go down as his service time increases.

The Brewers might not have been willing to part with a slate of top prospects for Tarik Skubal at the deadline, but look at the Rays, who bought low on ALCS MVP Freddy Peralta at the deadline. That's not a move we can imagine Harris making despite his abundance of resources.

There's always a risk in letting a prospect go and regretting it, but it feels like Harris is so afraid to be wrong in the future that he won't take risks in the present.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow