Scouts downplaying concerns over Zyhir Hope is very good news for Tigers

It's kind of hard to tell who the centerpiece of the Tarik Skubal trade was — but that's a good thing for the Tigers. Both River Ryan and Zyhir Hope came with some big pros; Ryan was major league-ready(ish), but Hope was the more highly-touted prospect who didn't come with the same amount of injury baggage.

Hope got off to a slow start after the trade but was clearly feeling more like himself in September, when he finished out the season strong with a .333 average and 1.015 OPS in 42 at-bats. The Tigers sent him to the Arizona Fall League, where he has a nice .405 OBP through 16 games. He could be a candidate for an early-season promotion to Triple-A and could even factor into Detroit's plans later on in the major league season.

However, Keith Law of The Athletic put a slight damper on the mood around Hope back in September, when he noted, "He looks … rather out of shape, to put it mildly. He's still got tremendous bat speed, but the body has gone backwards, and he's moving and running more slowly than he did when I last saw him in March."

That's basically prospect evaluator code for fat-shaming, but an American League scout isn't too concerned.

"Zyhir, for me, is an everyday corner guy with both hit and power, quality at-bats and solid defense," they said, per Emily Waldon. "I think the performance will be more consistent as he matures with nutrition and conditioning, maximizing his athleticism. There will be some maintenance, but he’s athletic, and it's not going to affect his profile for me. If/when he hits, nobody will talk about the body."

AL scout refuses to buy into concerns over Zyhir Hope's conditioning despite earlier yellow flags

Hope seems to be taking the transition to the Tigers well, though it can't be easy when he's already been traded twice in his young professional career. On being "the guy the Dodgers traded for Tarik Skubal," he said, "It's no pressure. I'm gonna continue to play my ball and enjoy myself."

Hope's arrival, hopefully by the end of the 2027 season, will force the Tigers to firm up the outfield picture a bit, which is arguably overdue. MLB Pipeline gives his arm a 60-grade and overall field a 55 — decent enough numbers that'll play in right field, a position the Tigers have struggled to fill full-time. A Riley Greene-Max Clark-Hope outfield sounds pretty enticing.

Of course, the Tigers can't let him get away with skimping out on conditioning if there are real concerns, but he's putting together a body of work that should allow fans to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow