Tigers' dependence on Kevin McGonigle exposes root of Detroit's issues

Kevin McGonigle is the Tigers' best healthy player right now. Full stop. Sure, lumping pitchers and position players in together is kind of an apples-to-oranges situation, but we'll do it anyway, because he's the only guy wearing a Tigers uniform who's giving fans any reason to smile right now.

On Tuesday, McGonigle extended his on-base streak to 11 games with a walk and three hits, one of which was a game-tying, two-run triple. Jahmai Jones and Wenceel Pérez gave the Tigers a 6-4 lead before the bullpen and more bad defense spoiled everything again. Detroit lost their ninth game in their last 10.

The Tigers are a third of the way through the season but already feel like they're on the verge of drowning. McGonigle, the rookie, is keeping his head above water better than anyone else.

Accordingly, he hasn't gotten a day off since May 4. He's only sat for two full games and has only been subbed for once, when the Tigers were already getting blown out by the Mets.

AJ Hinch doesn't plan on letting him slow down anytime soon. During their series against the Orioles, he said of potentially giving McGonigle a break, "Not with how things have been going – and how he's been doing, holding up fine. [...] We're going to dig out of this together, and he gives us the best chance to do that."

He's not wrong, but let's take a step back for a second and recognize that this is actually a kind of depressing thing to say.

Tigers' refusal to give Kevin McGonigle a break just reflects poorly on the rest of the offense

This is not to minimize what McGonigle has been doing in his rookie season. Offensively, his at-bats are just as competitive and his contact is just as solid as evaluators hoped, if not better. He's a threat on the base paths and he's making obvious strides defensively.

What fans might take issue with is the fact that the Tigers are hoping that McGonigle is a savior. He was always going to be an important, exciting part of the lineup, but if longtime staples like Riley Greene, Spencer Torkelson, and Kerry Carpenter were actually able to build on solid 2025 seasons — like Scott Harris promised they would — they could give McGonigle some room to breath and find his way.

Greene, to be fair, has been excellent, but Torkelson has been downright terrible and Carpenter has missed almost 20 games to the IL. 2025 All-Star Zach McKinstry is batting below .200. Beloved utility man Matt Vierling isn't doing much better.

McGonigle might turn into the best hitting prospect the Tigers have ever developed. He might've signed an eight-year, $150 million contract to make him the new face of the franchise. But he was never supposed to be one of two, maybe three bright spots on Detroit's roster just over 50 games into his rookie season.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow