There are few non-player baseball personalities that Tigers feel more animosity toward than Scott Boras. This is not to the Tigers by any means, but our wounds are still relatively fresh after the very long Tarik Skubal debacle that he had a hand in subjecting us to for the better part of two seasons.
There are a lot of "what-ifs" that we'll never get an answer to when it comes to Skubal. What if the Tigers had offered a more competitive contract extension? What if they'd done it sooner? What if Boras wasn't his agent? Would he have been more amenable to accepting an extension from the beginning?
Tigers fans tend to err on the side of answering "yes" to the last question. Although the clients should always have the final say as to their own futures, Boras' influence is not to be underestimated. Cody Stavenhagen of The Athletic wrote on Thursday that Skubal fell under his spell early.
When Boras was in the courting process, Skubal initially intended to go with different representation. Boras paid him and his family a personal visit to lay out exactly why he should sign with Boras Corp.
"He basically sent me down every single number of draft, arbitration, free-agent contracts, everything," Skubal said. "The numbers weren't particularly close. I was like, 'Well, that's good information.'"
But according to Stavenhagen, Boras is also the reason Skubal was a Tiger in the first place.
Scott Boras reportedly pulled strings to make Tarik Skubal a Tiger in 2018
"Boras Corp. leveraged a longstanding relationship just to get Skubal selected. It was draft day in 2018, and the Detroit Tigers were preparing for their next pick. David Chadd, then the Tigers’ assistant general manager, was on the phone with [Boras Corp. VP Scott] Chiamparino. A player the Tigers were interested in — another Boras client — had just been selected. Chiamparino started talking up Skubal. The Tigers had scouted Skubal and had mixed reviews. They saw the upside. They also shared concerns over the surgery and the walk rate.
"Chadd conferred with then-scouting director Scott Pleis and others. They agreed to roll the dice on a hard-throwing left-hander."
Scott Boras giveth, and Scott Boras taketh away.
It's a double-edged sword for Tigers fans. We know exactly how good Skubal was in his prime, and how much he meant to the team and the city, but his last few months in Detroit certainly marred the way we look back on his tenure here.
According to some insiders, the Tigers are hanging around on the Skubal market and waiting to see if they'll be able to discount. That's not going to happen if Boras has anything to say about it, and they might be better off not dealing with him anyway.
