Tigers PR account gets flamed on social media for bizarre bullpen comment

The Detroit Tigers PR account probably thought it was dropping a nice little Sunday stat nugget. Instead, it walked straight into a ratio.

After a win over the Cincinnati Reds, the team account proudly posted that the Tigers rank third in the American League in OPS (.750) and fourth in ERA (3.95), adding that they’re one of just two teams to rank top four in both.

On the surface? That’s a contender’s profile. But baseball fans — especially online — don’t do surface-level.

A disgruntled fan immediately fired back, pointing out what anyone who’s watched this team in April already knows: the starting rotation is doing the heavy lifting, and the bullpen has been, in their words, a “hot mess.”

That’s when Tigers PR made things worse.

“Our bullpen ERA (4.36) ranks 7th in the American League,” the account replied.

And that’s when the internet collectively tilted its head.

Seventh… out of fifteen. Congrats?

This is where the disconnect lives. The Tigers are technically right — a 4.36 bullpen ERA isn’t bottom-tier. But anyone watching games, not spreadsheets, knows that number doesn’t tell the story. It doesn’t capture blown leads, momentum-killing innings, or the feeling of inevitability when the starter exits and the phone rings.

Tigers' aggregate pitching stats can't mask recent bullpen struggles

This isn’t theoretical frustration. It’s recent and repeatable.

Take April 16 against the Kansas City Royals. Keider Montero gave them six innings. Then the bullpen nearly gave it right back — Drew Anderson couldn’t record an out cleanly, and multiple relievers piled on runs before Colt Keith bailed everyone out with a walk-off. That became a theme.

Against the Boston Red Sox, a winnable game turned into an 8-6 loss after the bullpen surrendered six earned runs behind Jack Flaherty. Against the Milwaukee Brewers, it got worse — nine runs allowed in relief. And the rain-delayed collapse against Cincinnati? Two separate leads, both gone.

Individually, the numbers are just as concerning. Drew Anderson is sitting on a 7.30 ERA. Will Vest, despite some recent improvement, is still at 6.75. Even Kenley Jansen — a future Hall of Famer — has already blown two saves and is converting at 75%, well below his career norm.

Meanwhile, the rotation — bolstered by the offseason addition of Framber Valdez — has been one of the best in the American League. That’s the only reason the team ERA looks as clean as it does.

Which brings us back to the tweet.

This is the danger of leaning too hard on aggregate stats in a moment that demands context. Fans aren’t frustrated because they don’t understand ERA rankings. They’re frustrated because they’ve watched games slip away in real time, over and over again.

And rightly or wrongly, that frustration has a target: Scott Harris. The Tigers' president of baseball operations has made a habit of trying to build bullpens on the margins — journeymen, bounce-back candidates, overseas fliers. Sometimes it works. Often, it doesn’t. And right now, it’s definitely not.

The Tigers don’t have a fatal flaw. They have a fixable one. But until it’s fixed, no amount of social media spin is going to convince anyone this bullpen is anything other than what it’s looked like: a problem waiting to happen.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow