Detroit Tigers Free Agent Signing Predictions

Nov 12, 2019; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; Detroit Tigers executive vice president of baseball operations and general manager Al Avila speaks during media availability at the Omni Scottsdale Resort & Spa at Montelucia. Mandatory Credit: Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports
Nov 12, 2019; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; Detroit Tigers executive vice president of baseball operations and general manager Al Avila speaks during media availability at the Omni Scottsdale Resort & Spa at Montelucia. Mandatory Credit: Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports
3 of 3
Next

As the Detroit Lions enter the bye week tomorrow,  there will be some much-needed excitement and hopefully some fulfillment as the Detroit Tigers enter the waters of MLB free agency.

“The monotony and solitude of a quiet life stimulates the quiet mind”-Albert Einstein.  How does this quote from the brilliant scientist Albert Einstein have to do with the Detroit Tigers and MLB free agency? Simple, really. Down in Lakeland, Florida, the spring training home of the Tigers, the front office brass has a chart in which they have identified their free-agent targets or perhaps, trade targets.

The room is quiet minus the humming of phones going off on vibrate or perhaps a fun ringtone like “Eye of the Tiger.” No reporters or blog writers, just Al Avila, and his crew, similar to what you see in the movie “Moneyball”, pouring over the stats and numbers.

This scenario is really theater of the mind but in all seriousness, the front office is getting ready for tomorrow evening as at 5 pm tomorrow night, the “quiet period” ends, and teams can sign free agents or decide to pick up options.

With the labor talks between the owners and players digging their trenches,  it is hard to see whether teams will be aggressive or perhaps wait until the labor agreement gets cleared up to sign players. There is the invisible salary floor to consider and teams trying to avoid the luxury tax. In the case of the Cincinnati Reds, it is their opportunity to cut payroll.

For us, the contributors at all the FanSided blogs, it is our opportunity to speculate with as much knowledge as possible to see what directions their teams will take. For Detroit Tigers fans, it is their opportunity to speak their minds on who they would like to see wear the Old English D.

So I and a few contributors are making our official predictions and we asked you, the readers for your predictions on who the Detroit Tigers will sign. It is not only fun but it is a way to “shoot your shot” so to speak, for us, it is a way to see how wrong we are or how right we could be. Either way, this seems to be shaping up to be a fun off-season so let’s start the predictions.

Oct 31, 2021; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Houston Astros shortstop Carlos Correa (1) hits an RBI double against the Atlanta Braves during the third inning of game five of the 2021 World Series at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: John David Mercer-USA TODAY Sports
Oct 31, 2021; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Houston Astros shortstop Carlos Correa (1) hits an RBI double against the Atlanta Braves during the third inning of game five of the 2021 World Series at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: John David Mercer-USA TODAY Sports /

Detroit Tigers fans on Twitter

We conducted three polls on Twitter, one earlier in the year and one recently on who fans want the Tigers to sign as their shortstop. Chris Brown highlighted that recently in his Correa piece that back on an April 1st poll,  it was Trevor Story and more recently, it was Carlos Correa.

Correa’s playoff play certainly helped his cause and of course the connection to manager A.J. Hinch. Jon Heyman predicted the Tigers would sign him and the odds in Vegas even look strong.

I posed the question for positions of need (shortstop and starting pitching) and one “unexpected” signing. Here are some responses we got on our Tigers Discord channel. 

GhostMav: 

SS: Correa
SP: Jon Gray and Alex Cobb
Surprise: Kenley Jansen

Epcicd3c:

SS: Baez
SP: Eduardo Rodríguez and Andrew Andrew Chafin
Surprise: Kenley Jansen

Now, onto our poll with a nice variety of answers.

https://twitter.com/hshngoo/status/1456730253884276742?s=20

Alex Colome I thought was a solid pick despite his down year with the Twins. Chris Taylor was also a solid suggestion since he can play a variety of positions.

Now, we move on to our contributors.

Sep 14, 2021; New York City, New York, USA; New York Mets starting pitcher Marcus Stroman (0) delivers against the St. Louis Cardinals during the first inning at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports
Sep 14, 2021; New York City, New York, USA; New York Mets starting pitcher Marcus Stroman (0) delivers against the St. Louis Cardinals during the first inning at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports /

Our predictions for Detroit Tigers free agents

Here are Jacob Boes predictions:

Shortstop: Marcus Semien
The Detroit Tigers have been wary about long-term contracts in recent history, and although Avila has mentioned they are unafraid of a long-term deal, I can’t envision the club being willing to go as long as a Carlos Correa or a Trevor Story will require.

In Semien, they can still address the shortstop need long-term, but maybe on a 5-6 year basis rather than a 7-10 year length. There are risks with Semien, but Story and Correa come with risks as well. Risks would only be compounded by the length of their contract.

Starting Pitcher: Anthony DeSclafani
Sticking with the theme, DeSclafani would be a solid arm that is beneath the top tier of pitchers. Given the changes the Detroit Tigers have made with pitching coach Chris Fetter, it may not be necessary for them to shop at the tip-top of the market.

Ideally, a deal would be shorter-term–two or three years maximum. DeSclafani would effectively present a bridge between now and the return of Spencer Turnbull, who is recovering from Tommy John Surgery.

Unexpected Surprise: Chris Devenski
It isn’t some mind-blowing acquisition, but the Detroit Tigers have stated they’re set in the bullpen. Additionally, Devenski had Tommy John Surgery on June 5, 2021, making his MLB return around August, assuming things go as smoothly as possible.

Hinch has a connection to Devenski from his days at Houston and it’s likely a deal that could be on a minor league basis. If things go perfectly, it’s an arm primed for the stretch run. If not, it’s minimal risk and maybe the Tigers can re-examine for 2023.

Yooper:

SS: Semien
SP: Verlander
Surprise: Starling Marte

Yooper has been very vocal in bringing back Verlander. We shall see what Houston will offer the two-time Cy Young winner.

Chris Brown:

SS: Trevor Story. “I think they can get him for fewer years/money, and he doesn’t have the lengthy injury of Seager and Correa.

SP: Alex Wood: “The possible Dodgers connection”

Surprise: Chris Archer. “Just seems like a fun reclamation project..possibly as a reliever.

Now, for my predictions, I went back and forth about this for a while for a few days since our discussion on the podcast. So here are my predictions.

SS: Marcus Semien 

I say Semien for three reasons. 1. He can play second base.  Yes, I know the Tigers resigned Jonathan Schoop but Schoop could see more time at first base with Miguel Cabrera again. If Ryan Kreidler emerges early on in spring training or Triple-A, he can slide over to short and Semien at second with Schoop at first when Cabrera is the DH.

What about Spencer Torkelson? He could be called up in early summer and say, for example, Kreidler isn’t ready, you can have Semien at short with Tork at first. There are endless lineup combos with Semien. However, the point of signing him is to play short but we have seen Hinch move players around to strengthen his lineup.

Starting pitchers: RHP Marcus Stroman and LHP Andrew Heaney

Stroman is an ace that could make a huge difference for the Tigers in the AL Central and provide another veteran presence to Casey Mize and Tarik Skubal.

Now you may think I am nuts about Andrew Heaney, who struggled with the Yankees but look beyond the ERA for a moment. He is a lefty who was better than his ERA with a FIP of 4.85. He struck out 150 in 129 innings pitched with a K per 9 of 10.41.  He can miss bats and perhaps some work with pitching coach Chris Fetter may help him. He may not seek a huge deal but a chance to redeem himself.

Surprise: José Iglesias or a trade for RHP Luis Castillo

They could strikeout in the shortstop market and go for a placeholder like Iglesias because of familiarity but the Luis Castillo trade prediction is more or less, wishful thinking because he is entering his arbitration years and the Reds may not able to afford him, based on their recent moves or trade him at the deadline when his value increases.

Those are our official predictions. Let’s hope the Tigers can finally have some success in the starting pitching market. The last few signings have hit the IL so we shall see where they go to shore up the rotation.

Next. Saying Goodbye to Buster Posey. dark

Next